I was glad to read, in The Federalist, Daniel Brubaker’s recent piece, “Why Sharia Law Is Incompatible with the American Way of Life,” which took up on an earlier piece of mine in Al Hurra: “Why Sharia Courts Have a Place in Israel.” I was also humbled that Dr. Brubaker kindly introduced me as “perhaps the most articulate Muslim advocate of reconciling Islam with Western liberty.” But generous framing aside, I think his response missed some of my own argument’s finer distinctions and oversimplified the case I was actually making.
First, let me clarify what we are discussing. My piece never claimed that Islamic law, or sharia, is already compatible with liberal democracy in its classical, state-enforced form. It made a narrower and, I think, more useful claim: that a specific, limited kind of sharia observance—personal-status law administered by community courts that operate underneath, not above, a rights-protecting state—has a long working history in exactly the kind of societies Dr. Brubaker may want to defend: Israel and Greece, the latter being more liberal thanks to the European Court of Human Rights. If I had more space, I could add other non-Muslim states such as India, Thailand, Singapore, or Sri Lanka, which also maintain sharia courts for their Muslim citizens, adjudicating family matters such as marriage and divorce without violating national constitutions or laws.
These examples do not show “what Akyol wishes sharia to be,” in Dr. Brubaker’s words. They show existing realities in the world, which are much more complex than what most of the contemporary sharia alarmists in America imagine.