No one disputes that parenting in the digital age comes with new challenges, particularly as our education, entertainment, and work environments have increasingly migrated online. This has led many advocates to call for policy interventions in the name of protecting young people online, claiming that it would benefit young people’s mental health or address other societal concerns about kids these days. But even if that is the case for a particular young person, as Thomas Sowell wrote, “There are no solutions, only tradeoffs.”
In our new paper, “Online Age Verification Has Guaranteed Costs and Uncertain Benefits,” we point out six key costs or harms that should be considered when calculating such policy tradeoffs. Those costs are: