In a recent MarineLink op-ed, maritime consultant Rik van Hemmen argued that the Jones Act is a cost-effective means of meeting the country’s national security needs and that further debate on the law is a waste of time. Neither is true. The Jones Act is both a costly and ineffective means of addressing defense requirements, and debate over the law’s future—to be followed by profound policy changes—is long overdue.
The national security case for the Jones Act, which restricts domestic waterborne cargo shipments to vessels that are US-flagged, US-built, and US-owned, is fairly straightforward. Theoretically, such measures provide the United States with ships in wartime to transport equipment and supplies for the military, the trained mariners to crew them, and shipyards that can both build new vessels and repair existing ones. The problem is that the law delivers only a fraction of its advertised benefits, at a wildly disproportionate cost.