For nearly a decade, the conventional wisdom in Washington has been that protectionism is good for electoral politics. Most notably, Donald Trump won in 2016, when he promised to renege on existing trade agreements and impose tariffs on US trading partners for “ripping us off,” and once again in 2024, when he doubled down on his protectionist platform by promising “universal baseline” tariffs and higher duties on discrete US trading partners. From a theoretical perspective, this political instinct makes sense: appealing to constituencies that bear the highly concentrated costs of trade liberalization seems an intuitive strategy for electoral success. To the extent that protectionism truly carried the day in these previous elections—a debatable proposition—recent polling ahead of the forthcoming midterms suggests the opposite is happening: protectionism, specifically through high, sweeping tariffs, is not just failing to attract support among voters but has become a political liability for the president’s party.
For starters, Americans today care—a lot—about tariffs, a major shift from just a few years ago. In 2018, Cato’s Scott Lincicome documented that, according to various polls, trade was not a priority for most Americans, despite the heavy emphasis on it during the 2016 election. Meanwhile, only 1 percent of Americans surveyed by the Cato Institute/Morning Consult in 2024 listed trade and globalization as a top three issue. (Hence, why skepticism that protectionism propelled Trump to the White House is warranted.)