JD Vance’s book Communion devotes a chapter to arguing that policymakers have spent decades chasing GDP at the expense of his version of the greater good. I wrote earlier this week to show what Vance gets wrong about the country’s economic history—namely, that policymakers have never been the GDP-maximizers he makes them out to be. But even granting that premise, the chapter misfires in a deeper way.
Its greatest mistake isn’t to misunderstand GDP or even to misrepresent what policymakers aim for. It’s to conflate GDP statistics with a motive. Lots of things we do every day grow GDP, yet few of us wake up in the morning with GDP maximization in mind. GDP is a by-product of much human action and decisionmaking—decisions that are for the most part voluntary. Reading the chapter carefully, it becomes clear that Vance’s problem isn’t really with GDP per se but with people who make choices that contribute to higher GDP, but who don’t chime with his own view of what’s best.
Read the rest of this post →