Financial scams cost American consumers and businesses billions of dollars a year, so it’s good that Republican and Democratic legislators are taking notice. The House Financial Services Committee voted unanimously to advance H.R. 4936, the Taskforce for Recognizing and Averting Payment Scams Act, and the Senate is considering a similar bill. The bills would create a bipartisan task force to address payment scams. The task force would bring together federal agencies, banks, online platforms, telecommunications carriers, and other key players in developing coordinated approaches to stopping scams.
Scams are a real problem. But how do concerns about scams intersect with concerns about growing federal power, enforcement abuses, and overregulation?
Unlike regulations such as price controls, catching bad actors who cheat people strengthens markets. The goal is market-friendly, but the mechanisms might not be. Policymakers addressing a crisis may, for instance, create institutions, rules, or practices that erode liberty, markets, and individual rights. With this caveat in mind, I offer recommendations below that a new task force on scams should consider: