“The president hasn’t done as good a job of preparing the nation for the tradeoffs necessary to reconcile the hope agenda with the fear agenda.”
–William Galston, Brookings Institution
For more on Obama as “a bundle of contradictions,” see here.
“The president hasn’t done as good a job of preparing the nation for the tradeoffs necessary to reconcile the hope agenda with the fear agenda.”
–William Galston, Brookings Institution
For more on Obama as “a bundle of contradictions,” see here.
Washington Post sportswriter Sally Jenkins often has sensible things to say. And in today’s paper she makes some interesting points about hyper-competitiveness in sports and finance. But I think she was led astray by investor, college athlete, and Clinton Treasury appointee Roger Altman:
There is a strong natural connection between Wall Street and sports because “both are quite binary worlds, somebody wins and somebody loses,” according to Altman, who was a varsity lacrosse player at Georgetown.
That’s just wrong. In sports it’s true: somebody wins and somebody loses. If the Yankees beat the Red Sox, that’s a binary outcome with a winner and a loser. It’s what economists call a zero-sum game. If Michael Phelps wins the gold, then everybody else doesn’t.
But in the market both parties to a transaction expect to gain. I get a meal, the restaurant owner gets my money. I get a salary, Cato gets my production. As Murray Rothbard wrote in the Concise Encyclopedia of Economics:
The mercantilists argued that in any trade, one party can benefit only at the expense of the other—that in every transaction there is a winner and a loser, an “exploiter” and an “exploited.” We can immediately see the fallacy in this still-popular viewpoint: the willingness and even eagerness to trade means that both parties benefit. In modern game-theory jargon, trade is a win-win situation, a “positive-sum” rather than a “zero-sum” or “negative-sum” game.
No doubt businessmen do like to “win” — sometimes they say “money is a way of keeping score.” They like to make the deal and block their competitors. Sometimes their testosterone may even impel them to make deals that aren’t economically rational, and the market has a way of punishing such decisions. But the people who make the deals — both parties, all parties — all expect to benefit. And usually they’re right. We’ve all bought things that we wish we hadn’t, or made investments that didn’t pan out. Most of the time, though, both parties to a transaction are pleased to make it and remain pleased after the fact. And the process of repeated positive-sum transactions creates economic growth and development.
Sports is different. The game may be fun, for both competitors and spectators. But in the end, as Altman correctly says, in sports “somebody wins and somebody loses.”
I’ve got a commentary over at NPR about how the health care provisions in the “stimulus” package are bad investments. Here’s a taste:
We desperately need research on the effectiveness of medical treatments, and the law includes $1 billion for that. Yet experience suggests the benefits of taxpayer-funded research may be zero…
[T]he law’s $33 billion for electronic medical records also fails the cost-benefit test. The CBO estimates it would be cheaper just to do the second MRI…
The law includes $115 billion in health insurance subsidies. Economists have no clue whether that passes the cost-benefit test either…
The law will finance expanded COBRA benefits with a $65 billion hidden tax on other workers’ health insurance premiums. That hidden tax will actually reduce wages and job creation…
The good folks at NPR encourage you to post comments.
(FYI, Cato will host a forum on comparative-effectiveness research on Tuesday, March 3.)
President Obama’s proposal to tax the thrifty to bail out those who contracted for more house than they could afford — and hearing people on the radio say “I scrimped and saved to buy a house I could afford, and now I’m going to pay for people who overextended themselves?” — somehow got me to thinking of the old fable about the ant and the grasshopper:
In a field one summer’s day a Grasshopper was hopping about, chirping and singing to its heart’s content. An Ant passed by, bearing along with great toil an ear of corn he was taking to the nest.
“Why not come and chat with me,” said the Grasshopper, “instead of toiling and moiling in that way?”
“I am helping to lay up food for the winter,” said the Ant, “and recommend you to do the same.”
“Why bother about winter?” said the Grasshopper; “we have got plenty of food at present.”
But the Ant went on its way and continued its toil. When the winter came the Grasshopper had no food, and found itself dying of hunger, while it saw the ants distributing every day corn and grain from the stores they had collected in the summer. Then the Grasshopper knew:
IT IS BEST TO PREPARE FOR THE DAYS OF NECESSITY.
Unless, of course, you can count on a government bailout.
You can subscribe to our YouTube channel here.
In one of the most “you’ve got to be kidding me!” stories that I’ve come across in a while, The New York Times reports that New York City wants to spend $45 million to retrain laid-off Wall Street financiers. This is so incredibly offensive that I don’t know where to begin. But I’ll give it a try nonetheless.
First, just because they are laid-off does not mean that they are poor. Won’t a lot of this taxmoney be going to, well, rich people who don’t really need it? Second, even if they now find themselves with nothing, why should the taxpayers come to the rescue? If they didn’t manage to sock away anything for a rainy day, then tough. Third, exactly what is New York going to retrain these masters of the universe to do? This ought to be well worth watching. Fourth, if they’re smart enough and savvy enough to be the master of the universe, they are smart enough and savvy enough to get back on their own two feet without the hard earned cash pinched from some cabbie somewhere.
It’s as if The New York Times has become The Onion.
Dennis Cauchon of USA Today and Stephane Fitch of Forbes recently penned articles on the excessive nature of state and local government employee benefits and the threat taxpayers face as a result.
First, Cauchon reports that “State and local governments have set aside virtually no money to pay $1 trillion or more in medical benefits for retired civil servants…With bills coming due as Baby Boomers start to retire, states, cities, school districts and other governments may be forced to raise taxes, cut benefits or both — a task made especially difficult in an economic downturn.”
I would add that the task of cutting benefits for government employees is especially difficult because state and local politicians are generally beholden to the government employee unions. Even those policymakers not predisposed to carry water for the unions are hesitant to ruffle the feathers of a sizable voting block, not to mention a vocal one that still has a lot of regular citizens conned into believing government employees are underpaid, selfless, public “servants.” Trust me, I’ve witnessed this game first hand.
Cauchon also spotlights the big picture problem: “These medical costs are part of a larger burden taxpayers face in providing health care for an aging population. The federal government has a $1.2 trillion unfunded obligation to pay medical costs for retired federal workers and military personnel. Medicare and Social Security push the nation’s unfunded promises above $50 trillion.” He also notes that the same private sector employees who pay for these benefits via taxes are not so lucky: “Unlike private companies, most governments subsidize health insurance for retired employees.”
For more Cato work on unfunded medical benefits for state and local government employees, see here and here.
Second, Fitch reports on the outrageous pension benefits state and local government employees are receiving. This piece should be read in its entirety (warning: don’t read it standing up), but I’ll list a few tidbits here:
“Goss retired four years ago, at 42, from a $90,000 job as a police commander in Delray Beach, Fla. He immediately began drawing a $65,000 annual pension that is guaranteed for life, is indexed to keep up with inflation and comes with full health benefits…Given that the average man his age will live to 78, Goss is already worth nearly $2 million, based on the present value of his vested retirement benefits. Looked at another way, he is a $2 million liability to Florida taxpayers.”
“In private-sector America your job, assuming you still have one, hangs on the fate of the economy. If your employer ever offered a pension for life, like young officer Goss is receiving, odds are it has stopped doing so, or soon will…Four in five public-sector workers have lifetime pensions, versus only one in five in the private sector. The difference shifts huge risks from government to private-sector workers.”
“In public-sector America things just get better and better. The common presumption is that public servants forgo high wages in exchange for safe jobs and benefits. The reality is they get all three. State and local government workers get paid an average of $25.30 an hour, which is 33% higher than the private sector’s $19, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Throw in pensions and other benefits and the gap widens to 42%.”
“The recent market meltdown erased $1 trillion from municipal pension funds, Boston College’s Center for Retirement Research figures. That has left the average public plan 35% underfunded. With benefits inexorably rising, the shortfall will balloon to 41% by 2013 if stocks and bonds stay at current levels, representing an unfunded liability of roughly $1.7 trillion, according to the Boston College center.”
As I blogged back in October, shed no tears for state (or local) government employees. A former California state government employee cited in Fitch’s piece agrees with me:
Don’t shed too many tears for public employees, says Gary Clift, a 52-year-old Californian who speaks with an insider’s authority. Clift spent 26 years working for the state’s Department of Corrections & Rehabilitation, retiring in 2006. He’s now collecting 78% of the $112,000 salary he earned before stepping down and full health care coverage for life. Clift is thinking about using some of the public’s largesse to write a book about the outrageous ways public employees milk California.
Clift holds special vitriol for a state program that lets employees retire and return to work part-time as “consultants.” Some of the “retired annuitants,” known as retired irritants to full-timers, deliberately get themselves laid off to collect unemployment pay without having to even show up, Clift says.
Near the end of his career Clift spent two years in the Department of Corrections’ Sacramento headquarters analyzing legislation. The office’s mandate was to provide the governor with insights into how proposed laws would affect the giant prison system. Not surprisingly, Clift says his colleagues took another agenda more to heart: doing their union’s bidding and heading off anything that hinted at job cuts or lower salaries. Clift says he was the only manager at his former prison that he is aware of who didn’t put in for disability on retiring.
The prevailing attitude, according to Clift: “It’s just taxpayers’ money, so nobody cares.”
That would be the same state of California that just passed tax and debt increases to close a budget gap that was caused by a decade of runaway spending. The next time you read a story bemoaning the plight of “cash-starved” state and local governments and the possibility of tax increases to bail them out, bear these stories in mind.