This transcript was generated using AI automation and may contain minor formatting or transcription errors. Please refer to the original audio to verify specific quotes or context.
The Economics of It: The Economics of Electricity with Travis Fisher
Host: Ryan Bourne
Guest: Travis Fisher, Director of Energy and Environmental Policy Studies, Cato Institute
Ryan Bourne: I’m Ryan Bourne and this is The Economics of It. Today’s episode is the economics of electricity with Cato’s Travis Fisher. For years the electricity grid only got headlines during some freak weather event that caused the lights to go out. Now rising bills have made electricity a political battleground in regards to affordability. The enormous power requirements of data centers, including those run in artificial intelligence, have given frustrated households somebody new to blame for their high cost of living. The International Energy Agency has projected that data centers will account for nearly half of the growth in American electricity consumption through 2030.
But there’s another side to this story. A lot of these tech businesses standing ready to invest billions in these facilities can face years of waiting for the power they need because of our sclerotic monopoly electricity utilities. So must we choose between developing these new industries and affordable electricity for everyone else, or do both problems lie in a monopoly electricity system that makes it very difficult to build new supply? Cato’s Travis Fisher has been promoting an idea that he calls consumer regulated electricity, allowing private electricity networks to serve new business customers, physically separate from the existing grid. Travis is Cato’s director of energy and environmental policy studies and has worked at the Department of Energy and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. So Travis, welcome to The Economics of It.
Travis Fisher: Great to be here. Thank you.
Ryan Bourne: American households have, of course, been suffering with a high cost of living across the board. Electricity prices are up about 40 percent since the pandemic. Now, a lot of that owes to the general inflation we’ve lived through. You know, headline inflation’s price levels up 28 percent. So it explains quite a lot of that. And obviously, things like natural gas prices are up as well. But there seems to be something broader going on here with the cost of electricity. So what’s your kind of working model for why the relative price of electricity has gone up so much over the recent years?
Travis Fisher: Well, I would focus on the last 20 years or so when we really didn’t have that much of an increase in overall demand. But the main task in terms of policymaking was to change over the supply. So you had a lot of replacement of especially coal assets with new natural gas, but also a new wave of, in some cases, mandated and subsidized wind and solar. And so costs were already shifting anyways. And then we layer onto that now, this new growth in demand, and we were already going to be short on supply. And now this new demand, I mean, prices are only bound to go up.
Ryan Bourne: So where is that demand coming from?
Travis Fisher: About half of it, in rough terms, is from the data center build-out. Another significant chunk is when we electrify other portions of the economy, especially the transportation fleet. We have more EVs, for example. That’s only going to be—
Ryan Bourne: Electric vehicles, right?
Travis Fisher: Yes. And then to some extent, just overall economic growth. I mean, we have advanced manufacturing. A lot of that is inherently electrified. So think like robot arms in factories. So there’s a decent amount of all of that. I would say 40 to 50 percent, though, is the data center build-out.
Ryan Bourne: So the way that this has become politicized reminds me a bit of trade policy. When I first joined the Cato Institute, most of the people working on trade policy were highly technocratic lawyers talking about things like anti-dumping rules, you know, very, very niche topics. And I think people working on electricity for a long time, you know, it was an unsexy topic, right? You needed to be in the weeds of the regulation. Now all of a sudden, it’s been politicized because of this big increase in demand that we’re seeing, coupled with the supply restrictions from events overseas and the net zero agenda and things like that.
Now, you’ve been warning for a long time that our electricity system, the grid systems that we have in place, are just ill-equipped to deal with these big increases in demand. And indeed, this is a point that Cato’s been making for about 20 years, right?
Travis Fisher: Yeah. And so to be clear, I’m still very boring and technical, but the topic of electricity has become interesting. So I’m more popular at cocktail parties now than I was 10, 20 years ago. But yeah, the moment, I think what’s really interesting about this is we, some people use the term deregulated, that the electricity sector has been partially deregulated. That’s not fair. And there are Cato papers from the late 90s that outline exactly why they’re restructuring. I prefer to use the term restructuring. Restructuring wasn’t going to work. It was essentially bound to fail. And I think that’s coming to a head right now.
The fundamental problem is if you have a heavily regulated network, basically all we did was freed up the generation side. We never freed up the wire side. So transmission lines, for example, are still very heavily regulated. That system doesn’t expand easily. And we knew that. And the variable was, will we ever see a new increase in demand? And that was an open question for about 20 years. It seemed like the answer might be no. We know for sure now that the answer is yes, and we’re struggling to expand.
Ryan Bourne: So as I understand it, the thought process for a long time behind the type of system that we have is that if you have this monopoly, overseeing what’s termed like a natural monopoly, having one grid system, you can kind of really bear down on costs. There are lots of economies of scale. You know, the more we build up the networks, the more you can spread those fixed costs over a number of customers. So hopefully, you can push prices down. You avoid a lot of duplication and things like that. I mean, was that ever a good model for electricity? Has it been something whose time has come and gone? Or was it kind of a flawed model from the start?
Travis Fisher: Very avant-garde in the 1890s. And this is the kind of argument that actually made a lot of sense. I mean, you have to give it credit. If you have economies of scale, you want a very large network. The larger, the better. And you can bring average costs down. The bigger the network gets, the higher the total demand served. And you could point that out on sort of a whiteboard model, how that would work. So it did have its merits. Average costs did fall over decades. And it sort of seemed like it was working. But what that doesn’t get you is any sort of dynamic change. So that’s a very static view of the world. If you introduce something more Schumpeterian, Austrian market process type arguments.
Ryan Bourne: So like Joseph Schumpeter, famous Austrian economist from the early part of the 20th century.
Travis Fisher: Exactly, famous for coining the term creative destruction. We’ve had very little creative destruction in the electricity sector. And that’s predictable. It’s a heavily regulated enterprise. So in this model where you have one utility serving a large area, that utility has very little incentive to innovate. Every incentive is to try to get as much through the regulator as possible. So then the regulator sort of becomes the customer instead of actual customers wanting maybe different things. So that’s where we’ve been for about 100 years. And it’s predictably slow. We thought the stability was probably a good attribute. It cuts both ways though. If you’re very stable, very slow, very methodical in the way you operate, you’re not going to respond well to fast changes in demand.
Ryan Bourne: So let’s look at the current problems through both ends of the telescope. So the thing that we talk about a lot and that’s been highly politicized is that International Energy Agency prediction that through 2030, about half of the demand growth is due to be to the build out of these data centers. Now, of course, that’s very different from saying that they use half of all electricity. We’re talking about the change in the coming years. Now, there’s been a bit of a debate in Washington recently about the impact that data center growth has on rates, has on the prices that customers pay.
There’s been some like correlation analysis that appears to suggest, well, actually in certain areas with more data centers, prices haven’t gone up as quickly as in other areas with fewer data centers. Now, one could imagine that that might be because there’s some latent capacity in the grids in certain areas or you’re able to spread those fixed costs over a wider range of customers and push down prices relative to where they would have been. But it makes intuitive sense. I think that if you’re gonna have a huge surge in demand over time and you need to build out more capacity, that’s gonna push up rates. So where do you see the balance of evidence on the impact that data centers are having on customers’ actual prices that they’re paying?
Travis Fisher: So far, it looks like you can point to downward pressure and you can point to some rate cases where states have actually reduced retail rates because of the data center demand. What I think is happening though, it’s in part because there was sort of slack capacity on the grid that was then sort of absorbed by these large customers. I think if we’re talking about new demand now, pretty much every part of the grid is tight. So new demand now means you need to bring on new supply. And the open question is, how much is that supply gonna cost in terms of both the generation assets?
So we’ve pretty much limited ourselves to higher cost generation assets. We’ve closed a lot of coal plants. We are fresh out of Big Hydro. That was the big driver early on, thinking like a hundred years ago. That’s very low cost energy, but we’re sort of running out of those assets and building instead combinations of new solar storage, gas, et cetera. These are higher cost assets that just fundamentally, there’s almost no way the rates can go other than up.
Ryan Bourne: So how much of that challenge moving to kind of higher costs, new forms of generation is policy driven? Obviously, you’ve got a lot of states pursuing net zero and anti-carbon agendas. Or is it that the coal is just not as economic as it once was?
Travis Fisher: This is why this area is so complicated. It’s all of it. So there are federal rules on power plants that through a lot of cold water on coal plants also made it unclear whether we’d be able to build new gas plants going forward from the Biden era rules. Those have changed, but that sort of policy uncertainty at the federal level is going to only increase risk and increase rates. States, about half of them still have some kind of either binding renewable portfolio standard or net zero mandate, that kind of thing. That only drives up rates.
Case in point, Virginia. Ground zero for the data center build out has the Virginia Clean Economy Act, which mandates that the utilities go net zero by the late 2040s. So if you’re not able to build, in some cases, the lowest cost assets are new gas plants. But if you have these net zero mandates that are going to bind in a matter of less than 20 years at this point, you don’t build those assets because you have to comply within 20 years. So there’s a little bit of all of it. But the overall pressure is increasing rates.
Ryan Bourne: And I know that you’ve written a lot about how the federal kind of regulatory swing from one administration to the next where one administration wants to ban new coal and then the next administration wants to ban new wind farms in various places. So that’s driving a lot of the regulatory uncertainty there.
Travis Fisher: Yeah, and these projects take longer than four years to build. So the rules change every four years and one party cancels half of the assets, the other party cancels the other half. It’s a bad situation in terms of new supply.
Ryan Bourne: So I think it’s no secret that we’re having trouble meeting the moment, both because of the regulatory environment and just the sheer lack of supply flexibility because of the political games being played. So the direction we usually think about this is the impacts that AI and data centers are having on electricity rates. But there’s another way of looking at it, which is how much the AI build out is being held back by this electricity system that’s unable to power them in a cost effective and timely manner. Now you’ve argued that there are huge delays as a result of the system that we have. Can you just kind of quantify those a bit and tell us how companies are trying to get around those delays that they’re facing?
Travis Fisher: Yeah, we knew about the delays in terms of connecting generation assets to the grid. That queue was years long. It has been years long for a while. So we’re thinking four, five, six years to even plug in a new generation asset. Now what’s been interesting is you have large customers that also want to connect and that queue, that sort of wait in line if you’re a large customer, it really is growing to five, six, seven years. In some places, case in point again, Virginia, it’s more like 15 years to be studied and included and plugged into the grid. So that amount of delay for a lot of industrial customers is the same, if you’re in a high growth, fast industry, that’s the same as the utility saying, no, we can’t serve you.
Ryan Bourne: Yeah, time is money, right? So you’ve come up with a policy proposal for this and you call it consumer regulated electricity. Now that name I think is a little misleading. We’re not asking individual households to all of a sudden become utility commissioners. But what you’re imagining is a situation where if you’re a potentially big customer looking for electricity generation, you can effectively create an off-grid, private grid where you partner with a generator to actually power you outside of the existing system. So in terms of like public policy, what’s to stop big customers, big tech companies from doing this already? Why does it require a public policy to achieve that objective?
Travis Fisher: Well, to be very clear, some companies are getting creative anyways. I would point to the case where Google acquired Intersect Power and has become a vertically integrated data center plus power company. And those sort of intra corporate sales are not regulated. What becomes regulated is if company A sells to company B. So if you as a data center company or as mining operation or a new factory, if you would rather not be the owner operator of the power plant, if you’d rather just buy electricity as a service, that transaction is a retail sale and it’s regulated.
Ryan Bourne: So as I understand it, you can either be completely vertically integrated, you producing your own power, but if you choose to partner with another company and go off-grid, you then become regulated as if you’re a utility in many places.
Travis Fisher: Exactly, so that retail sale, most state laws are written so that any retail sale of electricity is a regulated public utility transaction. That sale itself makes you a public utility. And I think that made sense when we only had the one grid now that we have possibly multiple private grids. I don’t think it makes sense to deem that sale, even though it is a retail sale. Let’s say it’s from a company like Chevron to a company like Amazon. The whole point of public utility regulation is to protect the consumer. If it’s Amazon who’s the consumer, I’m not sure they need protection by bureaucrats. So that whole thought experiment of every retail sale being a regulated transaction, I think we need to rethink that completely, especially when it’s a private grid, especially when it’s a very sophisticated customer.
Ryan Bourne: So why would those regulations be so devastating? Why would being regulated like a public grid be so devastating for these private grids?
Travis Fisher: It is a showstopper for most companies that prospect of becoming a public utility, mostly because of the paperwork. It’s a heavily regulated environment. You need a team of experts to even know how to navigate it. And you fall under scrutiny that would scare away the average business. So in that world, every single investment that you make is scrutinized by, usually it goes by different states, but the Public Utility Commission of state X. And that state has, let’s say it’s a board of five people that vote on whether or not you can make an investment in an asset.
That makes sense if you’re in this cost of service environment, the cost plus where everything you invest in goes into someone’s rates. In the private sector, in a private grid environment, it makes no sense to regulate investments. Those investments are, you know, that’s a business transaction between buyer and seller. And it doesn’t really impact the mom and pop retail residential customers. So the idea that you would need to go through that permission process, it doesn’t make sense.
Ryan Bourne: So what specific regulatory changes would be necessary in many places to make this effective, make this economic?
Travis Fisher: So we’ve set it up as you can, it’s as simple as change the state law. So you would change the public utility code or wherever the law at the state level, wherever that lives. So it says a retail sale is a regulated transaction and you have to run everything through the Public Utility Commission, which is essentially a board of bureaucrats that tell you what’s possible and what’s not. So already this is like very fundamentally un-American approach. But when you want to do this off-grid setup, I say none of that should apply. In that case, you go to the place in the, you know, in the state law where it defines public utility and say, if you’re not touching public wires, you’re not a public utility and therefore not subject to these public utility regulations.
Ryan Bourne: So you’ve already alluded to this, but this is not an imaginary or kind of speculative idea. There are already case studies out there of firms pursuing this route and state governments actually changing the regulations to facilitate it. So can you just talk us through some of the examples that they’re already kind of seeing in existence?
Travis Fisher: A few of them, so I would highlight Ohio and in 2025 they passed a law called HB 15 that essentially allowed this. It doesn’t allow for any grand scale of network, but it allows this transaction between merchant supplier, merchant customer. And there is an off-grid setup that actually went live about a month ago in New Albany, Ohio, and it’s serving a data center. So we have possibly the first large scale example of a data center that’s actually being supplied off-grid due to a legal change that was made at the state level. Similar laws in Utah.
If you squint, the laws are different in each case, but if you squint, West Virginia and Oklahoma have similar laws and we’ll see exactly which versions take off. I still think all of these, they’re a step in the right direction. Each of them could be expanded in certain ways to either be more resource agnostic on the generation side, be more customer agnostic on the demand side, and be larger scale. For example, the West Virginia law has a, it’s a microgrid law and they have sort of an acreage limit. So you can’t get too big. I think all of those could be expanded.
Ryan Bourne: So you’re saying in your ideal world, these regulatory carve-outs, it wouldn’t depend on what type or how you’re generating the electricity and it wouldn’t depend on what type of customer you are. It could be a data center, but it could be a factory or other manufacturing plant or whatever else.
Travis Fisher: Exactly. What’s front and center in Wyoming, for example, is the trona mining industry wants to expand and they’re going to the utility and saying, we would love more service. Please, can you give us a little bit more service? And the answer is wait seven years. Now people are not sitting still. When they hear that news, they say, we’ll figure out another way. So that is a combination of off-grid, bring your own generation. There’s a suite of options that you can use and we’re seeing people get very creative because the need, that time preference, the speeds of power, the amount of money on the table, especially on the compute side is massive. So they’re going forward. They’re not waiting for utilities.
Ryan Bourne: So you talked about the project in New Albany, Ohio. And as I understand it, in terms of the time it took to get that off the ground, it was huge time cost savings for the company. It was Meta that did that?
Travis Fisher: It was an affiliate of Meta called Sidecat and the supplier is the Williams company, a gas pipeline company. And very conveniently, they are tapping their own gas pipeline and they’ve built gas generation assets right on top of the pipeline. So onsite generation serving an affiliate of Meta and the time difference really is if you wanted traditional utility service in that same area, it would take something between five and seven years. What they did from first application to in-service date was 17 months. So that amount of speed, it is a more expensive way to do it, but we’re seeing for the first time what people are willing to pay for that speed. And that’s the one thing they can’t get from incumbent utilities is fast service.
Ryan Bourne: So your argument, as I understand it, is that this would help solve those two problems that we were talking about earlier. Because in this instance, the company was able to get the generation off the ground much, much more quickly than they otherwise would if they had to go through the utility. But at the same time, because this is separate from the normal monopoly grid, you kind of leave that political pressure that there might be upward demand pressure on rates for the rest of the system. So you kind of insulate it from politics to a certain extent while getting the facility online sooner.
Travis Fisher: Right, I think it does both in probably the cleanest way. Cause we’ve seen things like Trump’s ratepayer protection pledge. And the idea is the new data center demand should not increase costs for anyone else. If you’re physically separate, that’s probably one of the cleanest ways to ensure that your costs don’t spill over to others. We’ve seen other examples in other states where even companies that have signed the pledge, both the customer side and the utility side, there are still costs that spill over. It’s a messy accounting process. The regulatory process is really obscure and it’s not really transparent to the average person. So the cleaner way to do it, I think is just be physically separate and that’s the best way to contain costs.
Ryan Bourne: So I imagine one reaction that people might have to this is to say, okay, but we’ve got a dysfunctional grid and these companies are able to work around it. And that’s fine for these big players, these big tech companies, but what about the smaller manufacturer that’s suffering under the current system? Well, we’ve got an increase in demand that perhaps is not all gonna be met by these off-grid private systems. Utilities, I imagine might say, well, we need some big customers to help balance our grids and to help ensure that we spread those fixed costs out.
But I know that you’re quite taken with the idea that this grid competition, competition for the grid, could actually lead to improvements on the monopoly regulated grid as well. So can you talk about why you think that might work, that kind of dynamic competition might have positive effects?
Travis Fisher: Yeah, well, we have to almost speak by analogy because we haven’t really seen this in practice yet on the grid. Two analogies that I point to, school choice. That is one of the areas where folks would say, well, that you’re gonna get two systems. You’re gonna get sort of the bad schools and the good schools, and everybody’s gonna go to the good schools and the bad schools will get worse. I think what happened in practice instead was the bad schools, just the element of competition improved both. And the other example is NASA to SpaceX. We got used to the idea that NASA was basically the only way to do space, space travel until we saw, and this was what about a year or two ago, that heavy booster come down and land itself and get caught with chopsticks.
That was the moment, that was an aha moment for me that, wow, there are other options and the private sector is amazing at even things like space travel. And we’ve never really had that moment on the electric grid to say, oh, we have this leap, this step change. And what’s happened in the case of NASA and SpaceX, the SpaceX competition, not only are they innovating, they’re trading back and forth, almost like cross-pollinating the things that they’re learning. I could see the same thing happening on the power grid. You would learn and experiment and do dangerous things on the private systems, and then the things that work out really, really well, you can transfer them back to the public system.
Ryan Bourne: You don’t mean dangerous in terms of being unsafe, but you mean dangerous in terms of just looking at new ways of doing things that perhaps have never been conceived before.
Travis Fisher: I mean, financially risky, I also mean in the SpaceX example, there were a lot of explosions. I don’t know that anybody got hurt, but a lot of—
Ryan Bourne: I’m not sure that’s the best way of selling it.
Travis Fisher: A lot of rockets blew up. But that’s not the kind of thing that you would want to experiment with on the public grid. And I’m not saying there’s gonna be any power plant explosions or anything like that, but the idea that you would do things that are too risky for a public utility to take on. And you have to keep in mind, they’re only following incentives. If your rate of return is capped, you’re not gonna go after very risky things. You’re gonna go with the stable, easy to approve, easy to put in your rate base and sort of go along, get along, but very little innovation.
If instead you allow for a private sector with uncapped gains, you could go, you know, sky’s the limit to completely beat up the analogy. But that is what I’m looking forward to is what does that look like? We see SpaceX now, we can compare that to NASA. We don’t have that example of what does that look like on the grid? What does a private grid look like? What does the Elon Musk version of a power grid, like cut everything that doesn’t work. The things that work poorly, improve them and do it on a matter of the same day, not apply for the change and have it come through years later. So the public grid is really bad at these sort of innovative leaps. And I think that’s where, if we allow these private grids, we’ll learn a lot from them. And in fact, they will improve the public grid.
Ryan Bourne: So this relates to the point that you’re making out about Schumpeterian competition, Joseph Schumpeter, because his big idea is look, we can spend all of our time trying to regulate small marginal improvements to the way things work. But what really drives improvements in living standards and innovation in the long run is people coming along thinking of completely new ways of doing things, completely new ways of providing electricity, completely new ways of, you know, forming grids that people wouldn’t have perceived as being economically feasible before, but now they are. So it’s good that we closed that loop on Schumpeter.
I wanted to bring him back. Now, this sounds like a relatively modest experiment when you put it like that in terms of structure, right? So you’re saying you’ve got these new customers, private investors, willing to do things, willing to take risks. Why shouldn’t they have the freedom to do this off grid? So who opposes this policy? Who is against it? Who are you battling against when you advocate for this?
Travis Fisher: Two main camps. One, of course, is the incumbent suppliers. If you’re an incumbent utility, you like the situation you’re in, this competition is perhaps an existential threat or at least perceived to be. I don’t think that’s gonna be the case. I think it’s gonna be more of, in the NASA and SpaceX example, there’s gonna be a lot of back and forth. Both can coexist. The other place I’m seeing, I think this is temporary opposition, but a lot of these private grids that are being built today are powered by gas. So if you have a natural gas-fueled boom, and we saw it with shale, we are awash with gas.
There’s parts of the country that have very low cost gas because the main object is the oil and you get some gas along with that. Some of it’s being flared, but it’s an emissions question. So there’s some opposition from environmentalists who see, well, this is a way to have a lot more supply and most of it presently is gas power. That means increased CO2 emissions. My counterpoint to that, because I have no counterpoint to the incumbent utilities. They’re gonna stick with their guns. They have a business model that works for them. I aim to disrupt that, but I see where they’re coming from.
On the environmentalist front, I see this being actually a testbed for a lot of new technologies. And a lot of the new ones are greenhouse gas emissions free. So you think geothermal, nuclear combinations of solar and storage, there’s all sorts of cool stuff going on. I think a lot of it, even though in the very short term, you’ll see a blip and increase in greenhouse gas emissions, because it’s mostly gas fueled. I actually see long-term this being a driver and a testbed and a proving ground for greenhouse gas emissions free technologies like geothermal and nuclear, et cetera.
So I actually think that’s been the key all along is if you want to decrease global emissions, you have to find something that’s globally scalable. It almost doesn’t matter what we do in the US if we can’t scale it globally. So I think this could be the answer. I mean, we could solve the speed to power problem on the one hand, simultaneously put a huge dent in greenhouse gas emissions globally.
Ryan Bourne: So their complaint would be that state mandates that say a certain proportion of your generation has to be from renewables or whatever, those regulations wouldn’t apply to the private grids?
Travis Fisher: It depends how they’re structured. This gets really deep in the weeds, but in the case of Virginia’s law, it applies to the investor on utilities only. So it wouldn’t, by the letter of the law, apply directly to them. If it applies statewide, it would apply to any assets in the state. So it depends how the state structured it. I think in terms of the split, it’s maybe half and half, but I wouldn’t aim to change the renewable portfolio standard or net zero laws just to accommodate this. I think if a state has a statewide standard, the private grid should follow that same standard.
Ryan Bourne: So what regulations, if any, would still apply to these private grids? Presumably because there are some spillovers of any major activity like this. You could face noise pollution, air pollution or whatever. So presumably a lot of state regulations of activity in general would still apply, right?
Travis Fisher: Well, and federal. And I think it’s an open question on the way EPA is gonna interpret these generation assets on private grids. At the local level, all noise, safety, emissions, all of that still applies. So it’s not an unregulated paradise of, do whatever you want and you can emit and make all the noise you want. It’s a very different approach. The only thing you’re relieved of is that economic regulator and the idea that you would have to ask a state board for permission to make an investment. That’s the piece that we really need to make this permissionless.
Ryan Bourne: And so it’s only the economic piece. It’s not the environmental piece. So presumably there could be some other benefits as well, right? So one thing that you hear a lot about these days is risks from rogue AI swarms and things like that, that they might take over a whole electricity grid. Presumably that becomes a lot more difficult if you’ve actually got a lot of private grids competing, got some like latent capacity that’s difficult to knock out if you get these AI swarms. So do you envisage that this type of competitive grid system could also improve the country’s resilience in some ways to those types of external attacks?
Travis Fisher: Absolutely. I think so. I mean, we’ve seen some statements from the Department of War. I have trouble calling it that, that they want—
Ryan Bourne: Let’s stick with defense.
Travis Fisher: Let’s stick with defense. That’s the legitimate role. Whatever that department is, they have made statements that they wanted to island their operations. And that’s for resilience reasons. And I think if you wanted that same amount of resilience, especially if you’re on a part of the grid that you think is subject to a lot of bad weather, for example, it would make sense to island anyways. We’re seeing a decent amount of islanded operation where it was sort of naturally needed out in the middle of nowhere, some mining operations, things like that. So we know we can do this. And if you wanted an air gap, there are multiple reasons to do it, but that is an extra one, that this is a security measure that if the public grid goes down, it doesn’t affect you.
Ryan Bourne: There are many different ways of defining resilience as well, but presumably for the companies, having these private grids would make them more resilient to changes in politics as well that you just talked about.
Travis Fisher: Yeah, and that’s something that I only explore occasionally because it’s a dark thought. We have gotten used to the idea that President Trump is very pro data center. And he is, and so far he hasn’t changed his mind on that. After the next election, we don’t know January, 2029, if the president is gonna be as pro data center as President Trump is. So I could imagine a world where there is a new federal decree, imagine an executive order that says, I hate data centers so much that they may not connect to the grid and all sorts of concerns about computational loads and how they impact the grid, costs going up.
You can imagine myriad reasons that a new president could say, I just don’t like this situation at all and you may not connect to the grid. In that case, I think it makes a lot of sense to go ahead and build out the other options, the options that would allow you to move forward even in a federal paradigm that doesn’t want you to expand.
Ryan Bourne: So you wrote the chapter in Cato’s handbook on affordability about energy in general. And there is a lot of political pressure on politicians at the moment to do something about electricity bills. So got a lot of proposals out there at the moment, things like rate freezes, data center moratoria, various subsidies or orders for keeping certain power plants open and things like that. Now, a lot of those measures amount to deferring costs rather than dealing with the supply crunch that you’re talking about. But is there anything that kind of can be done proactively on that side?
Are there any reforms at a federal state or even local level that could actually help facilitate more supply and improve the functioning of the existing grids, even aside from the reforms that you’re looking to push for private grids?
Travis Fisher: Yeah, and at the state level, I would say if you have supply constraints, ease them, you can move the compliance state back. For example, at the federal level, there’s a lot of interesting stuff going on. So I’m gonna get the name wrong. Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, BAAJA, is the federal permitting reform that has emerged from the Senate. And we’ll see that move through the process. I’m optimistic that it will pass and it includes a lot of good reforms. For example, projects that cross multiple states, there’s way too many ways for a state to cancel a project or for someone suing a project into oblivion.
You can essentially stop the work on these projects just by saying, we found something in your environmental impact statement that you didn’t cross a T on page 9,000 and you stop work on the project. That’s sort of an absurd way to do it and I’m glad we’re reforming that. I think that will have a huge impact. And that’s in terms of enabling supply, that has been a huge barrier. The permitting paradigm that we’re in, you can essentially stop anything. So I look forward to a world where that is not the case. We’ll see exactly how much supply we get from that.
I will note though, even if it makes, for example, high voltage transmission lines, way easier to build, that there’s still a time lag on that. Let’s say this bill passes this fall, it makes it easier to build transmission lines. Those are probably seven to 10 years out going into service. So we still have to solve the short-term problem. But there is good news on the federal front.
Ryan Bourne: And how much do you worry that some of those kind of net zero relating mandates at a state level are actually inflating people’s bills right now? And could there be things done at a state level to mitigate some of that?
Travis Fisher: Yeah, this is a very well-worn subject. The econometrics are very clear. The rates are much higher in states where the RPS is binding. So where you have a renewable—
Ryan Bourne: RPS, could you just define RPS?
Travis Fisher: Renewable portfolio standard is generally the suite of policies. Some go all the way to a net zero mandate. Usually, the old form was 15% renewable by 2015, and now it’s 50% renewable by 2050 and tends to be sort of whole numbers like that. But that’s the case, and I still think 29 states plus DC. So it’s not a niche issue. This is the kind of, the majority of states have this. Fewer of them are binding. For example, the state of Texas had one, surpassed it, and hasn’t reenacted a binding one. So there are some that are sort of old news, but what’s really interesting about that is it follows exactly what you would expect if you limit supply, if you get very specific about the types of supply you can have.
East Coast states have offshore wind mandates, for example. It’s a very expensive way to do it, to say you may only use this one state-approved resource. So it follows, it stands to reason, and it also, we see it in the data.
Ryan Bourne: It seems another area of low-hanging fruit if you wanna build out electricity, transmission lines, and things, is not to make it more expensive by imposing tariffs on the inputs to those transmission lines. That seems like an easy win. Politically very difficult for the president to reverse on that, but that’s another recommendation of your handbook chapter.
Travis Fisher: Yes, and so it’s not just transmission lines, it’s the shortage that we have in almost every component of the grid. So everything from gas turbines that you would build in a gas plant, those turbines are on a backlog, also heavily tariffed. Transformers, another grid asset in very short supply, very high cost now, in part because we had energy efficiency mandates that were driving changes in that, but also, I mean, the tariffs, we import those, and a lot of those are essentially custom-built for a specific site. So we don’t really mass produce them. We definitely don’t mass produce them in the US. So all of that is subject to tariffs. So we have on top of a supply crunch, a bunch of tariffs on top of the things that are already gonna be expensive.
Ryan Bourne: So we began with talking about the dual challenge of higher bills and the fact that you’ve got this kind of delay in getting new supply online that’s hindering the build out that data centers require. And your argument is essentially, look, let these big customers, let entrepreneurs come together and provide power to these companies off-grid as a way of mitigating both of those problems. Paint us a picture. Let’s imagine we come back in five years time. What does success look like? How would you be able to judge whether this policy has actually been successful? Do you imagine that it could fundamentally drive down prices? Is it about mitigating price increases? How do you kind of picture a successful world where this policy has been implemented?
Travis Fisher: Well, it’s gonna be hard to predict, but I think the big benefit is gonna be the innovation piece. And so that may drive costs down. And especially if the off-grid networks really work and more people move to them, that’s less pressure on the public grid. So I think it would stabilize rates on the public grid, but it’s the innovation piece. I think the thing that’s gonna be so hard to predict is what technology emerges that makes an entirely new industry out of this off-grid setup. I could envision that being new nuclear. I’m not sure, but I think the fun thing for me is that we have this new wave of both very time-sensitive demand, but also demand for cleaner energy.
So the customers here, most data center companies have net zero pledges that they’ve put on themselves. So these companies are contracting for new nuclear, new geothermal. There’s a lot of new things happening. And I feel like the moment we’re in right now is growing pains. And we’ll see exactly how we grow over the next five years, but I’m optimistic that it will grow in new and innovative and interesting directions, kind of like the SpaceX chopsticks. I don’t know what the SpaceX chopsticks are gonna be on the grid, but I’m dying to see it.
Ryan Bourne: I think one of the really refreshing things with the way that you go about this is a lot of people in Washington have like a preferred technology in mind, right? So you have advocates for new nuclear, you have advocates for the oil and gas industry, you have advocates for renewables, but you’re trying to get the processes right, get the structure of the system right, to facilitate people to try things out and find cost-effective ways of doing things. Now, you’ve spent a bit of time in the administration. You went into the department for energy and you worked under the energy secretary, Chris Wright. What do you think his perspective on this is? Is he bought into this type of dynamic innovation that you’ve been advocating?
Travis Fisher: He’s very free market. I think he’s bought in. One thing that he’s done specifically is unleash new nuclear. So the first of a kind hurdle is massive. So the idea that you could get a bunch of new reactors to go critical in terms of actually getting nuclear reactions in a new facility, there were something like three or four that happened in the space of a year after establishing that goal. So he’s doing some really interesting stuff on the technology side. The thing I’ll note about the sort of level playing field argument, I see some parallels between the federal permitting reform and CRE or the private grid setup.
There’s some interesting psychology going on. It’s essentially a bet. If you establish this level playing field, either a brand new grid or permitting reform on the federal side, do you expect your favorite technologies to win? And if everyone does, then you get buy-in from both sides. So both left and right said, well, we’re sure that our technology is gonna win. So open up the floodgates. The same with private grids. When you talk about the concept of a private grid, you get a lot of technology advocates, nuclear, geothermal, et cetera, batteries. They’ll say, my God, this is amazing because I can build my stuff on this. And so if everyone’s thinking that way, if everyone’s optimistic about their own technology, I personally don’t care who actually wins. The process of the competition is gonna be great for consumers.
Ryan Bourne: Well, Travis has been really exciting watching you flesh out this proposal and advocate for it around the country. And I think it’s a good example of how when the economics changes and often when you get high prices in a particular industry, it can encourage innovation. And we’ve just got to remove as far as possible the state barriers that stop those higher prices leading to more innovation and lead into these fundamental new ways of doing things that could drive down costs for consumers. So really appreciate you being here. That’s all we’ve got time for today.
Travis Fisher: Thank you.
Ryan Bourne: That’s all for today’s episode of The Economics of It, a production of the Cato Institute dedicated to advancing individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace. Don’t forget to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And if you like what you heard, rate us highly on your preferred platform. I’m Ryan Bourne. Until next Thursday, goodbye.