New NAEP Scores Confirm ‘F’ in Feds

The recent elections made one thing very clear: Americans want a cheaper, smaller, more effective federal government. Today we have powerful evidence that a terrific place to start giving them that is education. New National Assessment of Educational Progress -- so-called "Nation's Report Card" -- scores are out, and despite years of massive increases in federal education spending, as well as nearly a decade of No Child Left Behind "accountability," stagnation is what we've gotten. Reading scores for 12th graders -- our schools' final products -- are lower than they were in 1998 and 1992. In math all we have is a slight bump between 2005 and 2009, and no data before that because NAEP changed its math framework, making today's results essentially meaningless. Looking at other NAEP tests -- notably the long-term trends exam that tracks from the early 1970s -- overall math achievement is almost certainly as lifeless as reading.

The Constitution gives Washington no authority to govern or fund American education, which is reason enough to get the feds out of our schools. If that doesn't do it for you, however, that federal meddling has produced nothing but expensive failure should clinch it: It’s time to listen to voters and get Washington out of education.