In case you hadn’t heard, we’re in the midst of “Banned Books Week,” a self‐righteous time of year when librarians in particular condemn efforts to get books booted out of public schools and libraries. It’s supposed to be a week in which Americans are shocked and dismayed over efforts to make Twilight novels, or The Catcher in the Rye, harder for kids to get for free.
Well, not “free,” exactly. I should say “on the public dime.”
Wait? This isn’t about outright burning of books, or expelling them from every home and Amazon list, but removing them from publicly funded institutions?
That’s right, and that makes such “banning” much more complicated than the American Library Association would have you believe.
You see, when a public institution chooses to buy a book with taxpayer money, more than just free speech rights come into play. So to does the right of taxpayers not to be compelled to support the speech of others. So book “banners” have just as much right to demand the removal of books as others have to demand that they remain on the shelves. It’s not censorship. It’s equal rights.
There’s another part of this: with public libraries and schools, government employees or some other governmental entity—maybe a selection committee—is choosing which books to purchase. That’s just as much discrimination against one or another book as demanding that a volume already purchased be removed. It’s just censorship on the front end instead of the back.
Here’s what I propose: go to your local public library and see if they offer every Cato book ever published. If they don’t, loudly decry their unconscionable censorship. Then, tell them that as long as anyone decides what goes into their library at public expense, someone’s rights will be trampled—rights don’t just kick‐in after books have been procured. Finally, let them know that the only way to end this unacceptable situation—and the constant, zero‐sum battles over who’s rights will be respected—is to get taxpayer money out of schools and libraries.
That will go over like a lead library cart, of course, but it will at least begin to address the real problem.