A Government Man

This afternoon Politico Arena asks:

Will the president's health care remarks today sway enough votes to pass ObamaCare through "reconciliation"?

My response:

Who knows? What they show beyond all doubt, however, is the mind-set of the president and the bill's proponents. Consider just a few of his opening words: "Everything there is to say about health care has been said and just about everyone has said it. So now is the time to make a decision about how to finally reform health care so that it works, not just for the insurance companies, but for America’s families and businesses."

Notice first the insinuation that health care works today for the insurance companies, but not for the rest of us. Obama has to have his foil, this man with no experience in the private sector and little understanding of how that sector works. But notice, more importantly, that we need "to finally reform health care so that it works" -- the implication being that this is a collective undertaking, the only question being how to do it. "We're all in this together." In the private sector, if we can't reach an agreement about some proposed undertaking, we walk away. That seems inconceivable to Obama. He's a government man: conceiving public solutions to private problems is what his life is all about.

I suppose you could say that government is so enmeshed in health care today that there are only public solutions to the problems government is largely responsible for having created -- starting with the favorable tax treatment employer-provided health care affords. But the direction of reform needn't be toward even greater government. It might be toward less government, as with health savings accounts. But that approach has been rejected from the start by Obama and his Democratic supporters. They move in only one direction.