A Contemporary Economist’s Account of the “Crowning Folly of Tariff of 1930”

“[T]here came another folly of government intervention in 1930 transcending all the rest in significance. In a world staggering under a load of international debt which could be carried only if countries under pressure could produce goods and export them to their creditors, we, the great creditor nation of the world, with tariffs already far too high, raised our tariffs again. The Hawley‐​Smoot Tariff Act of June 1930 was the crowning folly of the who period from 1920 to 1933….


Protectionism ran wild all over the world. Markets were cut off. Trade lines were narrowed. Unemployment in the export industries all over the world grew with great rapidity, and the prices of export commodities, notably farm commodities in the United States, dropped with ominous rapidity….


The dangers of this measure were so well understood in financial circles that, up to the very last, the New York financial district retained hope the President Hoover would veto the tariff bill. But late on Sunday, June 15, it was announced that he would sign the bill. This was headline news Monday morning. The stock market broke twelve points in the New York Time averages that day and the industrials broke nearly twenty points. The market, not the President, was right.”


– Dr. Benjamin M. Anderson [chief economist at Chase National Bank 1920–39], Economics and the Public Welfare: A Financial and Economic History of the United States, 1914–1946 (Indianapolis, Liberty Press, 1979, pp. 229–230)