Adding Free Speech Insult to Property Rights Injury

My friend and former law firm colleague Mark Sigmon — who co‐​authored Cato’s brief in the New Haven firefighters case — is representing a man facing daily fines for displaying a large political message on his house.


David Bowden was upset about the way he had been treated by the town of Cary, NC, regarding damage to his property during a road‐​widening project. This past July, Bowden hired someone to paint “Screwed By The Town of Cary” on the front of his house. A few weeks ago, the town gave Bowden seven days to remove the sign or face daily fines — $100 for the first day, $250 for the second, $500 for each subsequent day — for violating a local sign ordinance. That’s when Mark, who’s affiliated with the ACLU of North Carolina, filed a lawsuit on Bowden’s behalf. The complaint alleges that the town violated Bowden’s rights to free speech and to petition his government under the First Amendment and similar provisions of North Carolina’s constitution.


While the facts of this case are a bit colorful — and I’m sure Mark is enjoying the notoriety (here’s his appearance on Fox & Friends) — this is no laughing matter. The town appears to be compounding the damage it did to a resident’s property rights by now violating his rights to speech and political expression. At least now the town has agreed to refrain from enforcing its ordinance and levying fines until the case is resolved — which is essentially a capitulation to Bowden’s request for a preliminary injunction.


For more news on this story go here, here, and here. And you can read the ACLU’s press release and access all the legal pleadings in the case here.