No Compulsion on Women: Gender Egalitarianism in Islam
Watch the Event
Join the conversation on X using #CatoEvents. Follow @CatoInstitute on X to get future event updates, live streams, and videos from the Cato Institute.
Transcript
This transcript was generated using AI automation and may contain minor formatting or transcription errors. Please refer to the original audio to verify specific quotes or context.
No Compulsion on Women: Gender Egalitarianism in Islam
Moderator: Mustafa Akyol, Senior Fellow, Cato Institute Speakers: Asma Afsaruddin, Herman B Wells Endowed Professor of Middle Eastern Languages & Cultures, Indiana University Bloomington; Leena El-Ali, author of No Truth Without Beauty: God, the Qur’an, and Women’s Rights
Mustafa Akyol: Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Cato Institute. My name is Mustafa. I’m a senior fellow here at the Center for Global Liberty and Prosperity, and I’ll be moderating today this panel, this conversation titled “No Compulsion on Women: Gender Egalitarianism in Islam.”
Let me start by acknowledging a fact: in the modern imagination today, Islam can often be associated with misogyny, patriarchy, with the oppression of women. And this image is unfair and too sweeping. But it is not coming from nowhere, to be frank. There are some interpretations of Islam that are discriminatory against women, and we see this most severely in the case of the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, where women are deprived of the right to education, to go around without a male guardian, and to have equal rights with men. And across the Middle East as well, there are serious issues, like women’s mobility and autonomy, and inequality in marriage and inheritance. These are real problems and they deserve honest conversations.
But here is something that often gets lost to some of the people who look into this. Most of us are discussing this. Not every Muslim agrees with patriarchy. Many of them believe in gender equality. Also, there are Muslim scholars themselves who offer new interpretations of the religious tradition, new interpretations of Scripture, especially with a fresh reading of the Quran, and they are widely known as the Islamic feminists, in the sense of arguing for equal rights with Islamic arguments. In other words, the debate isn’t simply between Islam versus women’s rights, as it is sometimes framed. It is a debate within Islam, among Muslims, about how to understand the faith, as it happened in Christianity.
This is exactly the composition we will have here today, and I’m honored to be joined by two scholars who have done remarkable work on this exact question. One is Professor Afsaruddin, a professor of Islamic studies at Indiana University and author of numerous books on Islamic thought. She contributed a chapter to the Cato Institute volume that I edited and we published earlier this year, No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions: Islamic Arguments for Religious Freedom. Her chapter is titled “No Compulsion on Women: Gender Egalitarianism in Islam.” So, first off, joining us online from Indiana, she will share some of her insights from the chapter that she wrote for the book. It’s hard to summarize, but she will share some key points.
Then we will hear from Leena El-Ali, who is kindly joining us at Cato today in our auditorium. She’s the author of No Truth Without Beauty: God, the Quran, and Women’s Rights, a book that has received wide acclaim from scholars like Khaled Abou El Fadl, who wrote the foreword, and has been a bestseller in this field and may be a best-downloader. Best download. How many downloads have happened? Because Palgrave, the publisher, offered it as an open access book. What was the latest number?
Leena El-Ali: Yes, I actually just received the report last week. We’ve had over 520,000 accesses.
Mustafa Akyol: Okay, great. Wonderful. Congratulations, and a brilliant book. I myself read it. So from Leena, we will hear some commentary on Asma’s chapter and also some ideas in her own book. So let’s get into it. Asma, good morning. Let me start with you. First of all, I recommend everybody read your chapter in our book, as well as your other great works. And as I said, it’s not easy to summarize. You have very nuanced arguments and very interesting points, but in just maybe five, ten minutes, can you share with us some basic points you made in the book? Thank you again for joining us.
Asma Afsaruddin: Thank you. Well, good morning, everyone. Let me begin by thanking my good friend Mustafa for inviting me to be part of this panel discussion, and I want to thank Leena for participating in this conversation as well.
So let me begin today by referring to a prominent woman companion, or associate, of the Prophet Muhammad by the name of Umm Salama, who, according to the “occasion of revelation,” which is known in Arabic as asbab al-nuzul, listed in practically all commentaries on this critical verse, remarked to the Prophet regarding the Quranic revelations up to that point, saying, and I’m quoting, “I see that everything pertains to men. I do not see the mention of women.” End of quote. Subsequently, this particular verse was revealed, and now we can move on to the second slide, please.
And the verse reads: “Those who have surrendered to God among males and females, those who believe among males and females, those who are devout among males and females, those who are truthful among males and females, those who are patient among males and females, those who fear God among males and females, those who give charity among males and females, those who fast among males and females, and those who remember God often among males and females, God has prepared for them forgiveness and great reward.” And this verse is from chapter 33 in the Quran, verse 35.
Now, this new revelation used language deliberately inclusive of women and, above all, asserted the absolute religious, spiritual, and moral equality of women and men. No ifs, ands, or buts. It is no surprise, then, that Muslim women who can read and understand the Quran for themselves draw their power and strength from this holy book in recognition of their equal standing in society.
The Quran, in fact, confers specific socioeconomic and legal rights on women. Most importantly, the Quran gives women the right to inherit and hold property in their own names, even after marriage. The husband or other male relatives have no share in the property that belongs to them alone. Another important right Muslim women had from the very beginning of Islam is the right to learning and education. The Quran and the Sunnah, which refers to the Prophet’s custom and practices, repeatedly emphasize the importance of knowledge for both males and females. Muslim women also have the right to give or withhold their consent in marriage, to seek divorce under specific conditions, although this is a practice that is not encouraged either for men or for women, and to expect fair and kind treatment from their husbands and fathers in particular. The Quran recognizes the special gifts that women are endowed with as compassionate caregivers and nurturers within the family, and gives special recognition to the role of mothers within families.
One may well ask, how did these specific rights empower Muslim women on the ground? Our primary historical and biographical sources provide clear evidence of women’s robust participation in various spheres of communal and social life. Women’s presence in the public sphere in the first century of Islam is rather dramatically underscored by the fact that Aisha, the Prophet’s widow, assumed a prominent political role after her husband’s death. Now we can move on to slide three, please.
She is notably remembered for having led a revolt against the fourth caliph, Ali ibn Abi Talib, in 656 of the Common Era, for not having brought the assassins of his predecessor, Uthman ibn Affan, to justice. She made a public speech in the mosque at Medina, rousing supporters to her side, and went off to the battlefield with her army. Thus began the Battle of the Camel, which derived its name from the camel on which Aisha was mounted. Aisha was clearly exercising her right to command the good and forbid the wrong, a moral imperative that is equally binding on women and men. This imperative is explicitly stated in Quran 9:71, which states: “Male believers and female believers are the partners and allies of one another. They command the good and forbid the wrong, and they perform prayer, give the obligatory alms, and obey God and His Messenger. They are those upon whom God has mercy, and God is Almighty and Wise.” End of quote. Notably, women and men are described in this verse as enjoying an unqualified, equal partnership with one another because of their joint mission to promote what is good and noble in this world, and because of the qualities that they share in common as the moral stewards of this earth.
Throughout the pre-modern period, women also played prominent roles as teachers and scholars. Our historical records show that girls and women, especially from the upper classes, studied alongside males in private homes and in more institutionalized settings, and some became conscientious and beloved teachers of both male and female students later in their lives. Now let’s switch to slide four.
One may then logically ask: when the foundational sources of Islam, the Quran and Sunnah, recognize a woman’s ontological and moral equality to men, why has that not resulted in consistently gender egalitarian Muslim-majority societies? A good question to ask at this juncture. There are two quick answers to this question. First and foremost, we need to consider the hows and whys of the interpretation of sacred texts. Practically without exception, sacred texts like the Quran and the Bible have primarily been interpreted by men through the centuries, and it is their male-centered interpretations that have become authoritative. Second, we have to take into consideration the historical reasons for these changes over time. By the tenth century of the Common Era, outside cultural influences from Byzantine and Persian societies began to influence and reshape Islamic societies. Both Byzantine and Persian societies were highly hierarchical in nature, and the system of patriarchy, which refers to the unqualified domination of men over women, slowly became deeply entrenched in the Muslim world.
Let me now fast forward to the twentieth century. The pushback against patriarchal norms began in the twentieth century when reformist scholars, particularly women scholars, began doing pioneering work in reclaiming women’s voices throughout history and in separating what is genuinely Islamic, based particularly on the Quran, from culturally conditioned interpretations of Islamic principles. Muslim gender scholars and activists tend to argue that the main tools for countering social injustice toward women lie particularly in returning to the Quran and retrieving its gender egalitarian ethos, in order to empower Muslim women within an Islamic framework. This is a phenomenon that has been called Islamic feminism, as Mustafa mentioned earlier, and it relies on scriptural hermeneutics to challenge interpretations of the Sharia that lead to discrimination against women and the abrogation of their social and legal rights in Muslim-majority societies today.
In this vein, Muslim gender scholars and feminists questioned the interpretations of a number of key Quranic terms and concepts by Muslim male exegetes, a majority of whom understood these concepts in a gendered, discriminatory way. In the interest of time, I will pick just one term to demonstrate the consequences of what I clearly consider to be egregious misunderstandings of it. The term is darajah, which generally means a degree or rank or status. The word darajah famously occurs in Quran 2:228, chapter 2, verse 228, on divorced women. And I’m quoting now from the verse: “Divorced women remain in waiting for three periods, and it is not lawful for them to conceal what God has created in their wombs, if they believe in God and the Last Day. And their husbands have the right to take them back in this period, if they want reconciliation. And the rights due to the women are similar to the rights upon them, or the responsibilities they owe, with regard to what is good and equitable, bil-ma’ruf in Arabic. And the men have a degree over them, and God is Exalted in Might and Wise.”
This is a verse popular with those who want to retrieve a gendered hierarchy from within the Quran. Darajah, occurring in this verse, has been traditionally understood by pre-modern male exegetes to refer to a man’s degree over a woman, implying, according to most of them, but not all, a fundamental superiority of men over women. If, however, one resorts to a cross-referential reading of related verses in the Quran that contain the term darajah, different meanings emerge. There are seventeen other verses in the Quran that contain either the singular term darajah or its plural, darajat. I will mention just a couple in the interest of time. Quran 46:19 says everyone has a rank or degree. And Quran 6:165 states, “For He,” referring to God, “for He it is who has appointed you vicegerents over the earth, and has elevated some of you over others in degrees, so that He may try you in what He has bestowed upon you.”
And of course, the first verse, 46:19, refers to the simple fact that everyone, regardless of gender, has a rank or degree in respect to others on the basis of the characteristics they possess and the merit of their actions. The second verse, Quran 6:165, refers to darajat as trials from God, since humans who attain to certain ranks on earth also acquire certain responsibilities along with them that they are expected to discharge. Darajah therefore does not always connote privilege. It may actually constitute a trial or a hardship. Notably, none of the seventeen other verses I looked at link darajah to gender.
This broader perspective is helpful for better appreciating the contextualized meaning of darajah in Quran 2:228. The relevant part of the verse asserts that wives, since the context is clearly domestic, have rights and duties vis-à-vis their husbands that are equal to the rights and duties of husbands toward their wives. Husbands, however, have an edge or advantage over their wives simply by virtue of the fact that in the pre-modern period, men had the near-exclusive ability to earn money and provide financial maintenance for their families. This advantage is therefore purely functional and monetary in nature. Nowhere in the Quran is it then suggested that men, as a collectivity, are superior to women as a whole. And let’s move on to the final slide, slide six.
And so now, before I end, I want to put in a shameless plug for my 2023 edited volume, The Oxford Handbook of Islam and Women. My own chapter in this book, chapter four, provides many more critiques of questionable exegesis of critical verses concerning women by male commentators. And this is the study I drew from to write my chapter for the Cato volume that Mustafa edited. So, very well. Thank you, and I look forward to our conversation.
Mustafa Akyol: Thanks so much. Great. You reminded us of a very interesting aspect of the Quran: during the twenty-three years in which the Quran was revealed and proclaimed to Muslims, there are cases where women came and complained to the Prophet Muhammad, and then the Quran always came addressing that and generally saying something that actually helps or emphasizes women’s rights in that historical context. There are a few other examples of that as well. But thank you so much for this. And indeed, I recommend everybody check the Oxford Handbook of Islam and Women and your chapter in this book.
Now let me get back to Leena. Leena, thank you again for joining us. Your book and work are brilliant. Your work on this is also remarkable. What would you like to say on the points that Asma made, or what would you like to add from your own scholarship on this?
Leena El-Ali: Well, thank you again for having me, and nice to see you again, Asma. Of course, I agree with everything that Asma has laid out. There’s a lot to say, and it’s very difficult to try and pick what to focus on. But I will say that my own experience in looking at the Quran, and really reading it with a view to trying to get a sense for where God was coming from, if I may use that expression, when addressing women’s issues in those twenty-three years, I couldn’t help but get a sense that God was very much advocating for women, actually addressing situations that women at the time were encountering, and to the point of even responding to questions that some women would raise.
So for me, when I was looking methodically with that in mind, I got a sense of what we would call, in America, affirmative action. I got a sense of the divine being basically looking out for women and seeking to address unjust customs of the day, which is hardly surprising if we step back and think for a moment about how we think of Islam as a whole, as a religion. We, as Muslims, think of it very much as a religion of justice, don’t we? So for me, that reinforced what I had found, what I had felt when plowing through the Quran. With that in mind, it made huge sense to me that, of course, that would be one of the things that the Quran would address in those days.
Mustafa Akyol: Asma, let me go back to you. One thing you emphasize in your book and in the chapter you wrote for us, very rightly so, is what I would call the ontological and moral equality between men and women. The Quran doesn’t teach that women are somehow lesser human beings because of their gender. Quite the contrary. Adam’s wife was created from the same soul as Adam, so they are not unlike one another. And the verse you mentioned emphasizes believing men and believing women, pious men and pious women. They are all equal in the eyes of God.
But when we look into some of the legal verses in the Quran, there are some differences. Like polygamy is allowed, with complicated interpretations, of course, or on inheritance. However, an argument has been made by great scholars like Fazlur Rahman, I think, whose work has inspired most of us, saying that these were significant improvements in the very context of the Quran itself. Women didn’t have inheritance rights before; they didn’t have property rights in many parts of the Muslim world. So the Quran advanced women’s rights, maybe not to the level of full legal equality, as we would call it in the modern world. But we can look into the Quranic intention here. So there is Rahman’s “double movement” theory: you go back to the context of the Quran, you understand what changes the Quran brought, and with that intention, you can come to today and even reformulate some legal injunctions. So do you agree with this approach of the double movement, and the Quranic intention versus sometimes the letter of the law?
Asma Afsaruddin: Oh, yeah. Absolutely. I mean, Fazlur Rahman is definitely one of my heroes. I think a lot of our arguments are drawn from Rahman’s own methodology. The whole Islamic feminist scriptural hermeneutics is based on the kind of Islamic modernism that Fazlur Rahman advocated. And in fact, Amina Wadud, whom I like to call one of the four mothers of the Islamic feminist movement, was a student of Fazlur Rahman. So that is of direct relevance. So I can address the issues you brought up about marriage and divorce and inheritance. I can explain the Quranic intentionality behind these verses that are increasingly being revisited in the modern period.
Right. So let me start, then, with the question of marriage. Now, actually, in marriage, men and women do have equal rights. The verse that I read earlier, from Quran 2:228, describes husbands and wives as having reciprocal rights and obligations within the marriage, and they’re identical. But there is one additional factor that I will introduce into the conversation. Islamic marriage is supposed to be based on this notion of reciprocal rights and obligations in the Quran. For example, in 2:187, husbands and wives are described as each other’s garments. The Quran describes an Islamic marriage as one characterized by harmony and mercy. And these are characterizations that undermine the notion of an unequal marital relationship.
So the same verse, 2:228, ends by stating that husbands have a darajah, or degree, over wives in the domestic context. And as I indicated, this term has actually exercised the minds of the pre-modern male exegetes. But it’s clear from the context that, because it is the domestic context that’s being discussed, the darajah here refers to the financial responsibility of husbands towards their families. And this was simply a fact of life in the pre-modern world, when only men tended to be the breadwinners. It does not imply anything more, because the Quran also says, as I mentioned earlier, that everyone has a darajah vis-à-vis others. Now what does that mean? It means we all have attributes that give us an advantage over someone else. Some of us may be mathematical geniuses compared to others. Someone might be physically stronger than you or taller than you, and therefore a better basketball player than you and I can ever hope to be. So this is not a gendered statement. We just have different aptitudes, regardless of gender. But it does not make the one who possesses certain aptitudes or skills ontologically superior to someone who lacks a certain aptitude. Depending on our aptitudes, our responsibilities can be different.
So men’s ability to be hunter-gatherers and principal breadwinners in the pre-modern period gave them a functional edge over women when it came to divorce and inheritance rights, because they were the ones entrusted with the financial maintenance of their families. Now, male heirs typically get twice the share of females. There are some exceptions, though. But typically they will get twice the share of females because they were expected to use their shares to support their families. There was no such expectation of a woman. She can keep all her inheritance for herself and dispose of it as she pleases. Now fast forward to the modern period, when some women earn more than their husbands, or she is the only breadwinner in the family. In that case, she is the financial provider for her family and enjoys that same darajah over her husband. So again, I think we have to discern, just as Rahman pointed out correctly, the original intent of these verses. And if a woman is the principal breadwinner now and is supporting the family, then we could make an argument that she would get the same share of inheritance that a male financial provider for his family would get.
One of the main differences, and I always like to say this to my students, between those who are literalists and those who are reformists or modernists in their interpretations of the Quran is the kind of question they ask of the text, and not just of the Quran, but also of the Sunnah. Typically the literalists will ask how did the Prophet do a certain thing, whereas the reformists, the modernists, will typically ask why did the Prophet do a certain thing, or why does the Quran say what it does? So we try to discern the original intention in the original context in the seventh century. And once we have a better understanding of that context and the intention, we can apply that reasoning to our contemporary circumstances. And this is what the double movement theory refers to.
Mustafa Akyol: Yeah, exactly. I myself have given the example, when discussing literalism versus intentionalism: there are some sayings attributed to the Prophet which say a woman should not go alone, without a male guardian, for a certain distance, and this is still taken literally by the Taliban regime or some ultra-Orthodox circles in Islam. That’s why women cannot travel alone. But the intentional approach is that, well, the Prophet said this because in the desert, there were bandits and highway robbers, so a woman alone would be prey to these people. It was about a security caution in a very dangerous environment, which can be seen differently today in a modern world where travel is secure for most people.
Now, let me come back to Leena. It’s not an accident that both you and Asma and others who work in this field emphasize the Quran, going back to the Quran. But of course, Islamic law is derived not just from the Quran. Actually, much of it is derived from secondary sources, which is hadith especially. And you have a chapter in your book titled “Why the Quran Must Come First,” where you emphasize the primacy of the Quran over the hadith. Now, that is an approach I myself have. And in some chapters in this book we discuss apostasy, for example: can people change their religion according to Islam? The Quran doesn’t bring any earthly punishment to that, but one hadith, a reported saying of the Prophet, does. So you end up discussing the authenticity of the hadith or the exact meaning of it. Why did you see the need to emphasize the Quran over the hadith, and not vice versa, as some people actually really do? What’s your take on that?
Leena El-Ali: Yes, that’s a really important question. Thank you. To be honest, for me, I grew up just assuming that we all placed the Quran first.
Mustafa Akyol: First of all, where did you grow up?
Leena El-Ali: Oh, I’m from Lebanon.
Mustafa Akyol: Lebanon?
Leena El-Ali: Yes, yes.
Mustafa Akyol: I just wish safety to everybody in Lebanon and the whole region these days.
Leena El-Ali: Thank you. That means a lot. Thank you. So I just assumed, you know, I always understood it. For me, it was in the air. I sort of got it by osmosis that Islam, being such a fiercely monotheistic religion, is God, and then God, and then God, and then God, and then come the prophets, and then come other people, saintly people and so on and so forth. So I always assumed that that was the case. So it was really a shock to me, as I got older and started to hear things that didn’t gel with what I had understood from the Quran, that I started to realize that there were some hadiths that people would claim said such and such, a thing that the Prophet had said or done, et cetera, that clearly put women down. There are some hadiths. There aren’t a huge number, actually, there are only a handful, but they have been very powerful. They have been used in a very potent way, and they are pretty egregious. So, women in their understanding and religion compared to men, their mind is not… as if you had a woman leader, the nation would fail, and so on and so forth.
So I just want to try and encourage people to go back to what Islam as a religion is supposed to be. It’s a fiercely monotheistic religion. God comes first, and nobody is worth much next to Him, as much as we love our Prophet and all the prophets. But of course, we have to be certain that what we are told the Prophet said or did is actually what he said and did. Because we know, as Muslims, as believers, that there is no way that the Prophet would have gone against the Quran in anything. For us, as believers, he was the perfect implementer of the Quran’s messages, its spirit, its intention, et cetera. So there’s a tension there. Did the Prophet go off and do things that contradict the Islamic spirit on a given topic? We understand from the Quran, and as believers it seems to me evident, that that cannot be the case. And so we have to go back to the Quran and say, well, what did the Quran say? And of course, hadith contains a lot, and we value a lot of what the Prophet did and said that gels with, you know, he gave us wonderful examples of how to implement the Quranic messages and spirit. But when something seems a little bit off, then we have to question that, bearing in mind that, as many people know, and we know here, the Quranic verses were being written down on parchments by scribes over the course of the twenty-three years of the Quranic revelation, and within two years after the death of the Prophet, all of that was pulled together by the first caliph, Abu Bakr, into a single volume. And that is the collection that, nineteen years after the death of the Prophet, altogether, the third caliph, Uthman… the Quran that we have today.
Mustafa Akyol: All right. So, as the Quranic verses were being revealed and memorized, they were also being written down. That’s why there is no dispute among Muslims about the authenticity of the Quran. It’s a single Quran.
Leena El-Ali: Agreed. Exactly.
Mustafa Akyol: Not the same case with hadith.
Leena El-Ali: Exactly. Whereas, in fact, even scholars of Islam who are not Muslim agree that this is the Quran that we have today. It’s the same one as was had back then. With hadith, and this was one of the things I discovered as a novice at the time, the hadith was not being written down as the Prophet said and did something, and the Sunnah was not being written down. There is even a hadith which says the Prophet banned the writing of…
Mustafa Akyol: Of hadith.
Leena El-Ali: Exactly. He said, do not write down what I say, lest it be conflated in future generations with what God Himself had to say, with the Quranic verses, in other words, which is utterly logical if you think about it, that the Prophet would have been mindful of that. And so what happened with hadith is that it was over two hundred years later before that effort of trying to collect and write down everything the Prophet had ever said and done began. I mean, Bukhari, whose collection of hadith, as we know, is considered the ultimate collection amongst the six or more other collections, was himself not born until 178 years after the Prophet’s death. So there’s a genuine generational distance.
Mustafa Akyol: Two hundred years of gap.
Leena El-Ali: Yeah. And by the time they finished everything and we had the compilations that we have today, it was nearly three hundred years. So we just have to bear that in mind and exercise our minds, which God is very big on, using our mind, our common sense, when we look at these.
Mustafa Akyol: Yes. Indeed, hadith criticism, which is a big territory in itself and a very contested territory in itself, is, I think, a big part of any discussion about the place of Islam in the modern world and Islamic teachings today. This is also relevant not just for women’s rights but for many other issues. Apostasy and blasphemy laws also come from hadith, without any basis in the Quran. Also quite suspicious to me are the so-called hadiths which have teachings like “obey the ruler, even if he’s a tyrant, even if he’s an oppressor.” Well, was it the Prophet’s concern, or was that the concern of a ruler himself, who put these things in circulation two hundred years later? This is a huge discussion in itself, but I think being a little bit skeptical of the so-called fully authentic traditions, especially if there is a clear conflict with the Quranic principles and the clear words of the Quran, is, I think, a key issue in Islam today on many issues, not just women’s rights, but politics or civil religious freedom as well. Asma, what would you like to say on this issue? I mean, you are also a scholar of Islam, but of course you are very knowledgeable on the hadith approach, and many Islamic feminists also have taken a bit more skeptical approach to hadiths. So what would you say on that?
Asma Afsaruddin: So let me go back to that hadith that many like to cite today about how a nation will never prosper under a woman ruler. It does occur in the Sahih of Bukhari that Leena was referencing. Bukhari, of course, is, as you pointed out, the foremost scholar of hadith, and his hadith collection is the most revered one among Sunni populations. And the mere fact that this hadith is recorded by him gives it a certain stature, whereas a weaker hadith could have been more easily dismissed. But on closer scrutiny of this hadith, it’s clear that it is what’s known as one of the ahad reports. That is, it is a hadith that is narrated by very few transmitters, in this case primarily one transmitter. And that transmitter is the companion Abu Bakrah. Now, Abu Bakrah is highly problematic. He was actually whipped by Umar for giving false testimony. Now, one of the main criteria for assessing the reliability of hadith transmitters is to make sure that their moral characters are completely above reproach. Someone who gives false testimony and is punished by the caliph for doing so should not, under any circumstance, be considered a reliable witness. This is primarily Abu Bakrah’s testimony that begat this hadith, which is then recorded by Bukhari in his collection. So it does not meet the additional standard for a hadith to be widely disseminated before it can be treated as a hadith in which we should place our faith. If I can get a bit technical, if it’s one of the solitary traditions, that already is subject to considerable careful scrutiny and skepticism about its reliability.
But why do some people pick that? Because now we do have evidence of women leaders, and I think that’s been used to try to perhaps push back against this particular trend. There is a historical context for the circulation of this report by Abu Bakrah. Apparently, Abu Bakrah remembered this report all of a sudden, when no other companion had any recollection of such a statement ever having been made by the Prophet. But Abu Bakrah suddenly remembered it at the time of the Battle of the Camel, when Aisha was going off to the battlefield against Ali. So the timing, of course, also leads to considerable suspicion that he may have just generated it for an opportunistic reason.
So I totally agree with the discussion so far that many of these hadiths bear further scrutiny. In fact, there have been several attempts in recent times to subject even the Sahih collections to a thorough reappraisal. There have been attempts made in Turkey recently. Mustafa, you may be aware of that. And this is an ongoing critique of the whole hadith literature.
Mustafa Akyol: Yeah. And I think there is sometimes too much defensiveness on this among Muslims, like hadith collections are out of the question, untouchable. And I think some conservatives may perceive this as somehow being disrespectful toward the Prophet. Well, that’s not the point. The point is, are these sayings accurate? And they were written down, canonized, two hundred years later. I mean, writing down a little bit began during the Umayyad times, but still, as a collection, Bukhari, these were written more than two hundred years later. And as you said, narrations come from one person. That means one person, somebody else hearing from that person, somebody else a generation later hearing from that person. There are like four, five, six people in the chain who just by memory share these reports. And even, we don’t know, actually, whether some of these chains were created and projected back. There are studies suggesting that as well. So being a little bit skeptical of the authenticity of hadiths, which still teach us a lot of things, which teach us a lot about the history, which teach us how Muslims thought about these issues at the time, but not taking them as a second scripture next to the Quran which sometimes overrides it, is, I think, a key approach in any discussion about Islam in the modern world. Leena, would you like to add something on that?
Leena El-Ali: Yes, yes. I was going to say that there’s that game, it’s called the telephone game, where one person whispers something into the ear of another person, and then that person quickly passes it down a chain, and by the time it gets to the last person, what comes out is completely different from the initial words. So this is just to give an example, or just a metaphor, I suppose. But one of the things we also have to remember, that is a valid thing to think about, is, well, did the transmitter understand what they heard? Because there’s a question of people also transmitting what they understood, what they understood was the purpose. Because always, when you hear something and you relay it, it’s never verbatim. It’s usually your paraphrasing. It’s your understanding of what the purpose was and what the intention was. So there is that element that I wanted to mention.
And the other thing I thought I’d touch on is the word sahih, which in Arabic means the equivalent of “authentic,” you know, so indisputable. I think the fact that we call those two collections the Sahih of Bukhari and the Sahih of Muslim gives a lot of people the impression that anything that appears in those collections is therefore authentic, 100 percent verified, whereas actually what they did in those collections, by their own admission, is collect everything. And then they would sort of grade them in one way or another. For example, Asma mentioned that some would have just a solitary source, a hadith coming from just one person, as opposed to different sources, which makes it stronger.
Asma Afsaruddin: Exactly. So if a given hadith is relayed by several different people, then obviously it’s stronger. It has more standing than one that is relayed by just one person, and so on.
Leena El-Ali: So there are inevitable methodological gaps that that exercise was inevitably going to fall into, even as a lot of good things were done and transmitted and preserved.
Mustafa Akyol: Yeah, exactly. Thank you. Asma, there is also an interesting character that you mention at the very beginning of your chapter in our book, No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions: Samra. Who was she, and why did you find her story interesting? That’s why it’s at the beginning of the chapter. Can you tell us a little bit about that?
Asma Afsaruddin: Yeah, yeah, I love talking about her. So, Samra, some people say, was a female companion, one of the close associates of the Prophet Muhammad in seventh-century Arabia. But when we mention her name, we should also mention another prominent woman companion. She’s also mentioned in the chapter in the Cato volume: Shifa bint Abdullah. They were contemporaries, and both women served as the market inspector of Mecca and Medina, respectively, known in Arabic as the muhtasiba. This position would be the equivalent of the mayor of a city today, so it’s a very important position. As some of our sources inform us, Samra and Shifa were both selected by the second caliph among the Rightly Guided caliphs for this position. But a few sources suggest that Samra may have already held this position during the time of the Prophet, which would imply that he had himself appointed her.
One of the biographical sources we have at our disposal describes Samra, and I really love this description, as walking through the markets of Mecca with a whip in hand, commanding the good and forbidding the wrong. And that’s a direct quote from this source. So here was a woman given considerable authority in the public sphere, with the expectation that her commands would be obeyed by others, both men and women. By any token, the very fact of the selection of these two women for such visible positions of public authority was a noteworthy event. So details of Samra’s and Shifa’s professional lives have the potential to challenge and problematize some of the very deeply held gendered worldviews that are assumed to have defined Muslim societies since the seventh century. And it’s clear from their biographies that gender was no barrier in their case to assuming such public positions in early Islam. And clearly Muslim women were not secluded at this time. The later practice of seclusion that became prevalent during the Abbasid period was imported into Muslim society from other societies, particularly from Byzantium.
So it’s interesting that later jurists like al-Mahdi, whom I refer to in the chapter, were against the idea of having women appointed to prominent public positions. One was an exception, actually, and did not see any issues, any problems, with appointing women to such positions. So even among the jurists, there has been a healthy debate about the acceptability of appointing women to such positions. But Samra’s and Shifa’s cases clearly give the lie to this idea that women are not fit, either physically or mentally, or even at a spiritual level, to hold such prominent positions. The other thing I think that the examples of these two female market inspectors do for us is to invalidate the assumption of some of the later jurists that a woman’s voice is awra, or private, and should not even be heard. Right? I think that’s right. Yeah. You can imagine that. Yes, yes. Oh, yes. So, I mean, this by no means has died away. This is still a fairly prevalent assumption in certain circles. Now, how do you think Samra and Shifa were communicating with the people when they were walking through the marketplace with their whips in hand? I don’t think they were using sign language. I think they were actually reprimanding certain vendors for unethical business practices by using their voices.
And the other point I want to make, when we look at Samra’s life: if Samra was indeed appointed by the Prophet himself, then this act becomes part of his Sunnah and therefore should be considered normative for Muslims. In other words, Muslims should give serious consideration to women candidates for public positions, since it was part of the Prophet’s practice. I mean, this is a very important historical example that we can resurrect in the contemporary period to challenge the positions of people, you know, for example, serving the Taliban government, or in some of the Gulf countries where women have to seclude themselves, and even if they do go out, they’re not actually supposed to be very visible, and in some cases not even allowed to raise their voices in public. So history has enormous consequences for the lives of women, too. And it proves what Leena and I have been emphasizing throughout our conversation, the fundamental gender egalitarianism that is absolutely evident in the Quran and also in some of the hadiths. Not all the hadiths are demeaning of women. There’s actually a larger corpus of hadiths that are very laudatory about women. There is a hadith that says pious women will enter heaven well before pious men themselves. So there are many of those, and those need to be brought to our attention more than the hadiths that have misogynist content and that have gained wider circulation, I think possibly because the jurists were challenging some of the gender egalitarian practices of the early Islamic period.
Mustafa Akyol: Yeah, exactly. And it’s worth mentioning that Samra and Shifa, Shifa was overseeing the market in Medina against any possible fraud, which is something that the Quran takes issue with. Right. Because there were people selling grains and watering them so they’re heavier. So they were doing some fraud in the scales. But it was not about morality policing, which later became a part of the muhtasib’s role.
Asma Afsaruddin: Yes, which still is.
Mustafa Akyol: We need to dissociate those in different ways. But the beginning is actually very interesting here. And it was a free marketplace that Prophet Muhammad established. It’s worth mentioning that as well. He says no tax should be taken from this market.
Now, we have ten minutes left. There’s an online question I want to ask you both, from a reader in New York. It says, your work on this issue seems quite inspiring. What is the impact of your work and the broader work of Islamic feminists on the Muslim world itself? How are these ideas being received in Muslim communities? Let me begin with you, Asma, because you’ve been lecturing about this issue in different corners of the world, including in Malaysia. I think we both traveled there. You were… I was a bit less in Malaysia, but in Indonesia. And there are organizations devoted to these ideas, and you’ve been engaged with them as well. Can you say a little bit about how these ideas are being received, as well as the reactions and the objections?
Asma Afsaruddin: So since you brought up Malaysia, there’s a Malaysia-based organization called Musawah, which is an Arabic word that means “equality.” And they have been doing just amazing work there. Their whole methodology for effecting social change, and particularly changing people’s attitudes toward gender issues, is through education and challenging a lot of these pre-modern, androcentric, male-centered readings of the Quran and of the tradition that generate these discriminatory readings. So they’re again emphasizing that especially women scholars and their allies, male and female, everyone, need to go back to the Quran itself and again exhume this gender egalitarian ethos and reinterpret the verses in that light, which does more justice to the internal spirit of the Quran.
A lot of what Islamic law did, and you did correctly identify, of course, the Quran and the Sunnah as the two main sources of Islamic law, but let’s not forget also another source, and that’s custom, or tradition. And these are local customary practices that often exercise far more influence in the crafting of Islamic legal regulations, more so sometimes than the Quran and the Sunnah. A lot of what the Taliban is doing is actually coming from tribal law, the tribal law that is very prominent in South Asia, particularly in Pakistan and Afghanistan. And so a lot of these draconian measures, these punitive measures against women, are based more on tribal law than on a firm religious foundation.
So Musawah, and there are other groups of that nature, but they’re particularly prominent because I think they came along on the global scene first, and they’ve really become a global movement. And they started out as a smaller movement called Sisters in Islam. They’re in Kuala Lumpur. And I actually got to know quite well [name unclear in captions], who spearheaded that movement first, and then it transitioned to become a genuinely global and much more impactful movement under the name of Musawah. And they have started to bring about actually impressive change at the grassroots level. They’ve built coalitions with male jurists, with powerful men in the religious establishment, and some of them have become genuine allies. They’ve also encountered, of course, bitter opposition from very conservative types, right-wing groups who are totally opposed to the whole notion of revisiting Scripture and the idea of women, actually women scholars, taking the lead in this kind of scriptural hermeneutics.
I just recently came back from a conference in Istanbul, which was held by KADEM… am I pronouncing that correctly?
Mustafa Akyol: KADEM, yes.
Asma Afsaruddin: Okay. And they’re doing very similar work. They hold these workshops. They’re training women in this kind of work, educating them about their rights within Islam, and holding international conferences where they bring scholars, academics, and practitioners from all over the Muslim world and pick a topic for that particular workshop or conference. And so a lot of this work is going on below the radar. That’s why I think we often don’t tend to be aware of it, and they’re not necessarily publishing books, you know, their books can be found on Amazon.com and so forth. A lot of it is under the radar, but I think the kind of work that they’re doing at the grassroots level is achieving a critical mass. And you can see far more receptivity to these kinds of activities by women’s organizations, women’s NGOs, by those who are higher up in the administration and the government. I believe the current Turkish government is quite heavily involved in the work of KADEM. And I actually met the young woman who is now the chief adviser to Erdogan in the current administration, who actually joined us for part of the conference. This kind of high-level endorsement and support and patronage of these movements, I think, can make a huge difference down the line. So I think change is coming. We’re just not aware of it right now. It’s happening just below the radar, I think. But it’s achieving a huge momentum. And already I see evidence of change in the way that the issue of gender equality is being perceived and acted upon, in terms of policy changes and so forth, in a number of these Muslim-majority societies.
Mustafa Akyol: Thanks so much, Asma, and thank you for your work on that grassroots-level engagement as well. We have little time left, but I want to come back to Leena. Leena also, what has been the response you received, for example, for your own book? And how do you see this idea of gender egalitarianism in Muslim societies, defended with Islamic arguments, as you put it, how is it being received? And what are your observations on that?
Leena El-Ali: So, my experience so far, and the book came out, what is it, four years ago now?
Mustafa Akyol: Yes. For five, coming up to five years.
Leena El-Ali: Is that possible?
Mustafa Akyol: Possible, yes.
Leena El-Ali: Yeah. And from what I know, and what I know tends to come mostly from people who write in, or from responses to the talks and presentations that I’ve given in different venues, whether online or in person, I would say that 99.9 percent of the response has been positive. People have expressed relief, delight, at having the tools and the arguments at hand and ready. One of the things I do in my book is I summarize, at the end of every set of topics, so they can go back and pull out the relevant verses quickly and easily. I try to make it as user-friendly as possible, so there’s a lot of relief and delight, et cetera, from a lot of people.
But there’s also, in some parts of the world, honestly, like in the Arab world amongst young people, just disinterest. I think a lot of young people in the Middle East have just lost interest. They have bigger and more pressing issues, as they perceive their lives. You’re being bombed, and there’s a society, so they’re not really interested. So there’s very little interest amongst the young generation in the Arab world. Let me just speak for the area that I know best in this sense. It’s like, of course, of course there’s gender equality, but why does it take religious arguments for people to believe that and act accordingly? So there is that also.
Okay, but from elsewhere, where I have had more engaged feedback, where it really is important and people do want to know, it’s been very, very wonderful. And I’ve been very pleased with the responses of some religious leaders who have sought me out to give feedback, and occasionally from men who have had trouble convincing their wives, who feel guilty about this or that. So that was interesting to me. There are times when I have felt called upon to be a bit of a counselor. There were good men who were trying to convince their wives that they can relax and are not doing anything wrong, you can do this, you can do that, you shouldn’t feel guilty about this, you should feel more empowered. So that for me was very interesting. I mean, there are a handful of cases like that that came my way, but I thought it was worth mentioning because they were a surprise to me. But, you know, time will tell.
Mustafa Akyol: Sure.
Asma Afsaruddin: Can I just add one thing? The only time…
Mustafa Akyol: We’re almost out of time, but very quick.
Asma Afsaruddin: Yes. Oh, very short. The only time a book of mine was banned was in this country. An edited volume of mine that came out in 1996, that had to do with gender issues in Islam, was banned by the US Naval Academy. It was only recently unbanned.
Mustafa Akyol: That is so interesting. I hope that’s an eye-opener for a lot of people.
Asma Afsaruddin: Yes. Thank you.
Mustafa Akyol: Very interesting note. Thanks for sharing. I hope all your books will be freely read in all corners of the world, including here too.
Asma Afsaruddin: Yes. Thanks so much.
Mustafa Akyol: I mean, to both of you. And I think, Leena, the point you made is also very important. There are a lot of Muslims today in the world who see some unconscionable teachings in the name of Islam, people being killed for just their words, or women being deprived of education, and they think it is wrong, but maybe they don’t know the religious argument against it. Some may not care about it, but a lot do, and I think that’s why your work is really important. And the aim of this book, No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions, is actually to show those Muslims who see the value of freedom and equality and human dignity, but maybe don’t know the exact argument, to show them the arguments against those who say, yeah, yeah, we should kill people for blasphemy or apostasy, or women should obey their husbands and should not open their mouths. So that’s why I think the scholarship is really important.
Well, thank you so much for joining us from Indiana. This could have gone for days, but we have to end now. And thank you for joining us in our auditorium.
Leena El-Ali: Thank you.
Mustafa Akyol: Thanks to everyone who joined us online. And please consider downloading our book freely from our website and/or buying copies: No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions: Islamic Arguments for Religious Freedom. Have a great day.
Featuring
Herman B Wells Endowed Professor of Middle Eastern Languages & Cultures at Indiana University Bloomington
Author of No Truth Without Beauty: God, the Qur’an, and Women’s Right
The oppression of women in parts of the Islamic world is a serious human rights problem. This becomes more acute when misogyny gets justified by religious teachings, as seen most severely in Afghanistan under the Taliban. Many Muslims, however, believe in gender equality. That includes “Islamic feminists” who defend this position with fresh interpretations of scripture and tradition, especially through close readings of the Qur’anic text. Prominent among them is Asma Afsaruddin, a contributor to the recent volume, No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions: Islamic Arguments for Religious Freedom, edited by Cato’s Mustafa Akyol.
Join us to hear Afsaruddin make the case for gender egalitarianism in Islam. Leena El-Ali, the author of an acclaimed book on the same topic, will provide comments.
No Compulsion in Religion—No Exceptions
Most Muslims today are familiar with that remarkable Qur’anic statement: “There is no compulsion in religion…” (2:256). This verse, in a few words, seems to present an amazingly ancient precedent to a modern liberal value: that religion must be based on freedom, not coercion.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.