Slaughterhouse of Dreams

More than one in ten public high schools in America is a “dropout factory” according to an analysis by education researcher Bob Balfanz of Johns Hopkins University. At these schools, dropping out is the norm, not the exception, and their record of sky high dropout rates is consistent over time.


What can be done about it? The most obvious solution, to anyone familiar with school choice research, is to stop assigning students to these slaughterhouses of dreams, and stop sending tax dollars to them so that they can continue apace with their grizzly work. Instead, make it possible for all families to afford the schools of their choice, public or private.


Economist Derek Neal has shown that in urban areas, where most “dropout factories” are located, Catholic schools do a far better job keeping kids in school. African American students benefit the most. After controlling for differences in student background between the sectors, minority Catholic students had an 88 percent high school graduation rate, compared to just 62 percent for similar students in public schools. In other words, black students attending Catholic schools are almost one‐​and‐​a‐​half‐​times as likely to graduate as their public school peers. Still more impressive, these gains persisted through to college. Catholic school students were two‐​and‐​a‐​half‐​times as likely to graduate from college as similar public school students.


Jay Greene has found similarly favorable results for private schools (.pdf) in Milwaukee’s school choice program.


So let’s stop herding children into failing schools. Let’s give them a choice and a far better shot at educational success.