Policy Analysis No. 5

Immigration Policy: A New Approach

By Jennifer Roback
October 20, 1981

Executive Summary

Since economic migration is an investment, migrants tend to be young, ambitious, future-oriented, and, ultimately, economically successful. Immigrants, as both laborers and consumers, increase the country’s total wealth. The illegal-alien “problem” is largely a creation of current policies. Open immigration would help the American economy, save tax dollars, enhance America’s image abroad, and substantially reduce our foreign-policy costs.

President Reagan has proposed a new immigration policy for the United States that includes a slight increase in the number of immigrants permitted from Canada and Mexico, a ten-year waiting period for permanent resident status for illegal aliens already in this country, a revival of the guest worker (“bracero”) program, and stiff penalties for employers who knowingly hire illegal aliens. The proposal has been roundly denounced by Latino groups as well as by many members of Congress. Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.) said there was no demonstrated need for Mexican workers while Americans remain unemployed, and Sen. Alan K. Simpson (R-Wyo.) questioned the need for employer sanctions and asked why a counterfeit-proof identification card was not required.

In all the debate over immigration, no one seems to be considering the possibility of returning to America’s traditional open immigration policy. Yet that policy, which served us so well until the introduction of the quota system in 1921 and which allowed many of our ancestors to enter the United States, has much to recommend it. Both the theory of migration and our experience with immigrants suggest that an open immigration policy would be in the interests of U.S. citizens.

Download the Full Policy Analysis

Jennifer Roback is an assistant professor of economics at Yale University.


The 14 Most Common Arguments against Immigration and Why They’re Wrong

These are the main arguments against immigration — and they’re all wrong.

Why the Wall Won’t Work

The legal, practical, and moral case against President Trump’s border barrier.

Trump Is Against Legal Immigration Too

President Trump has been mostly consistent on legal immigration: He wants to cut it.