Health‐​Status Insurance: How Markets Can Provide Health Security

February 18, 2009 • Policy Analysis No. 633

None of us has health insurance, really. If you develop a long‐​term condition such as heart disease or cancer, and if you then lose your job or are divorced, you can lose your health insurance. You now have a preexisting condition, and insurance will be enormously expensive—if it’s available at all.

Free markets can solve this problem, and provide life‐​long, portable health security, while enhancing consumer choice and competition. “Health‐​status insurance” is the key. If you are diagnosed with a long‐​term, expensive condition, a health‐​status insurance policy will give you the resources to pay higher medical insurance premiums. Health‐​status insurance covers the risk of premium reclassification, just as medical insurance covers the risk of medical expenses.

With health‐​status insurance, you can always obtain medical insurance, no matter how sick you get, with no change in out‐​of‐​pocket costs. With health‐​status insurance, medical insurers would be allowed to charge sick people more than healthy people, and to compete intensely for all customers. People would have complete freedom to change jobs, move, or change medical insurers. Rigorous competition would allow us to obtain better medical care at lower cost.

Most regulations and policy proposals aimed at improving long‐​term insurance—including those advanced in Barack Obama’s presidential campaign— limit competition and consumer choice by banning risk‐​based premiums, forcing insurers to take all comers, strengthening employer‐​based or other forced pooling mechanisms, or introducing national health insurance.

The individual health insurance market is already moving in the direction of health‐​status insurance. To let health‐​status insurance emerge fully, we must remove the legal and regulatory pressure to provide employer‐​based group insurance over individual insurance and remove regulations limiting risk‐​based pricing and competition among health insurers.

Media Name: pa-633.jpg

Download the Policy Analysis

About the Author
John H. Cochrane

Rose‐​Marie and Jack Anderson Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution, Stanford University; Adjunct Scholar, Cato Institute; blogger, The Grumpy Economist