After Sen. Ron Johnson suggested Social Security should be “shut down” before walking back his remarks at yesterday’s Senate Budget Committee hearing, the Cato Institute’s Romina Boccia points to the contradiction between his rhetoric and his newly introduced Stop Scaring Seniors Act.

Despite describing Social Security as a “legal Ponzi scheme,” Johnson’s legislation would maintain scheduled benefits by shifting the program’s financing shortfall onto the federal budget, without addressing the underlying drivers of its rising costs.

In previous analysis, Boccia estimated that borrowing to maintain Social Security’s scheduled benefits rather than reforming the program could add roughly $46 trillion to federal debt between 2026 and 2056, including associated interest costs.

Boccia offered the following statement:

Johnson’s proposal focuses on mitigating the risks of benefit cuts for seniors while placing the entire burden of bailing out an overleveraged system on younger workers.

The risk to vulnerable seniors is real. Millions of Americans count on Social Security, and Congress can provide them with certainty instead of threatening them with an abrupt cut.

Legislators should slow the growth of starting benefits, reduce benefits for higher earners, and adjust retirement ages to longer lifespans to preserve current benefits for those who need them most without burdening younger generations with higher taxes or debt.

Instead of responsible reform, Johnson’s bill would keep seniors’ checks whole by borrowing more.

Romina is available to discuss Johnson’s proposal, Social Security’s projected 2032 trust fund insolvency, and reforms that could protect vulnerable seniors without increasing the burden on younger generations.