This transcript was generated using AI automation and may contain minor formatting or transcription errors. Please refer to the original audio to verify specific quotes or context.
Reclaiming America First: Opening Remarks
Introducer: This conference, the Institute for Peace and Diplomacy is pleased to launch Reclaiming America First. It’s a volume that brings together 13 contributors, co-edited by Arta and myself, to explore the geopolitical and political implications of the Iran War.
We obviously begin with a core observation that the war has deepened divisions within the American right over US grand strategy in the Middle East, and the meaning of America First itself. This initiative seeks to build an intellectual foundation for a foreign policy that is grounded in realism, sovereignty, vital national interests, and moving beyond any single personality, ideology, or political faction.
We are in this conference, co-hosted by Cato and us, and it is in that spirit that we welcome Congressman Warren Davidson. He describes his approach to foreign policy as grounded in realpolitik, an outlook that speaks directly to our aim of bringing hard-nosed realism back to US grand strategy. As one of just four House Republicans who supported a War Powers resolution to end the war in Iran, he has demonstrated a willingness to put those principles into practice. In January 2027, he will be only one of those four still serving in the House, making his voice on these issues all the more important. Please join me in welcoming Congressman Warren Davidson.
Rep. Warren Davidson: Welcome, fellow foreign policy nerds. Good to get together with you all. I was asked to speak to you today to kind of seek to define America First, and I’m humbled that my views and my voting record, you know, resulted in spending time with you.
I think about this, one of the clearest ways to define yourself is to define your enemies. Now, this is politics, not wars, so these are really ideological rivals, political rivals, some within the Republican Party and some, you know, more broad. But when you think of political rivals to America First or realism, of course, neoconservative comes right to the top of mind. Or, as I call them, the not-conservatives. Right? Because neoconservative is just another word for not conservative. And they’re, you know, rightly called the New Conservatives, but they’re really just old liberals. They’re globalists that are semi-nationalist.
And let’s be clear, just in the context of today, since they seem to be losing the debate, they’ve decided to resort to assault tactics and just insult people with ad hominem. So let’s be clear: neoconservatives are not defined by their race, religion, or ethnicity. They’re defined by their ideology. Globalists are also defined by their ideology, and their sort of the common good as they define it. Now, they’ve got their own heresy code. I think, you know, maybe you can call it woke or whatever, but there’s maybe degrees of wokeness within the globalist movement. But this would be, you know, kind of the mindset that dominates Europe, Canada, the UK, the Democratic Party, mostly. But it is the idea that it doesn’t even have to be good for America. It’s just good for humanity as they see it. And they definitely have a heresy code associated with it.
So then, you know, I’ll lump them together. Isolationists and pacifists, there, of course, very distinct. But in the current Overton window, “isolationist” has basically just become a pejorative to avoid debate, amongst others. That’s been kind of the idea that, well, of course, we’re people of action, so you’re just an isolationist. And of course, John Bolton would essentially accuse everyone that didn’t believe in more wars of being an isolationist. And in Georgia, I found this, my foreign affairs staff guy there, George, [unclear] a speech from 2003 highlighting the unpatriotic Americans. You know, of course, patriotism means that we squander our wealth and power on more wars in more places. So this is the idea that if you don’t agree with them, there has to be an insult.
So who haven’t I named in the enemies? Realism, or realpolitik. And you know, that of course is sort of the foundational ideology for America First. But that’s an old idea, and it clearly isn’t just American. So what really, then, is America First?
I guess I’ve started kind of clustering to kind of narrow this down. I’ve created this thing that unifies the political and ideological rivals as Uncle Sucker. Right? Uncle Sucker will do anything that somehow, I guess, fails to use America’s resources to advance America’s interests. Or maybe even worse, it squanders America’s wealth and power to undermine America’s actual interests. And I think that’s the fruit that we can see. If you look at the neoconservatives, their idea that more wars in more places has made us stronger is fallacious. It’s left us less free, less safe, more burdened by debt. You look at the ideology that’s undermined not just our power in the wake of the Cold War. It’s undermined our economy. Bankrupt nations are hard to defend. It’s undermined our culture in a lot of ways, because, you know, twofold. One is things like the Patriot Act, where they’re going to, you know, spy on you, of course, just to keep you safe, are undermining our culture. And all of this is kind of to support the kind of future that they want. It’s at least nationalist, though. So generally, the neoconservatives are concerned about America.
The globalists, on the other hand, there’s a massive overlap in the Venn diagram. They’re the ones that are pushing the pure open borders, and the idea that you can just flood the country. In the country, America First implies there’s America, that there is a place that’s not just an economic zone, that it is something that is united by something. Well, the question is, what is that? And I will say that’s kind of led to some of the uglier parts of America First. People have tried to glom on or co-opt the name America First to some pretty ugly ideas.
And I think what is an American is one of the important things, I think, for us today, as Republicans in the wake of this election, is to say, what is a Republican? And for me, the Declaration of Independence will always be far more important than the Constitution. Now, I just want to note it’s important to defend the Constitution, but the Declaration is the thing that really made America distinct. It recognizes that we are a people from all over, that what unites us is really first principles. And maybe that’s the thing: first principles more than America First. First principles, that we are endowed by our Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among them are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. And that is, I think, the founding idea. The Constitution, I think, imperfectly tried to protect those ideals. But it has either authorized the current situation or been inadequate to stop it. Right? So that’s the fight we’re in today.
And that’s why I say, like, even the name America First really is something that is grounded in domestic politics. So if you think about, well, the idea that America’s resources should advance America’s interests. I mean, Marco Rubio has taken great heat for basically making that point by closing down USAID. Did USAID do good things? Yes. But they were actively undermining America’s interests in a lot of places with America’s resources. I mean, they were running efforts to undermine foreign governments out of our embassies. And not just hostile foreign governments, not like Nicaragua. They were trying to undermine the government of Guatemala, and not because they wanted to do things that were disruptive for America, but because they were going to potentially be disruptive for migration. And so they were holding meetings to try to force Guatemalan members of Congress to, you know, vote to impeach and remove the prosecutor general. And when they got exposed for doing that, they kind of backed up a little. They were trying to leverage student visas for the Guatemalan members of Congress, for their kids in the United States, their ability to travel, every kind of coercive behavior.
So I think that’s the thing we look at, coercion. It’s not just swords and bullets that are coercive. We’ve seen all sorts of coercive behavior. And in the realm of jockeying for power and position right now, that is why I think it’s really important to understand who the America First people are and who’s basically allied with Uncle Sucker. Right? And the neoconservatives and the globalists are essentially unified, frankly. They’ve united to agree that the real threat are America First people, because America First people believe in limited government, and they want a smaller, more accountable government. Well, you’re clearly the enemy, because the left wing and the right wing of the globalists versus neoconservatives, they all want more government. And they know that the real threat is people that want less government. And so I think in a lot of ways the easy rubric is, well, who’s for more government and who’s for more freedom? And, you know, they at least know to say that they’re for more freedom. But again, you know them by their fruits, not their party affiliation, not their race, religion, or ethnicity. But, you know, what are they pushing for?
And unfortunately, you know, we’ve seen, maybe the best good news I’ve seen since the election results is that Jim Jordan is now selected to lead Republicans, unfortunately, in the minority. Why do I say that? Because his book title, and maybe it’s the most basic political advice ever, is: do what you said you would do. And if Republicans had delivered on what they said they would do in the 2024 election, this fragile coalition that unites the GOP, that holds America First, that holds the neoconservatives, that holds, you know, conservative-leaning libertarians and, frankly, some just pragmatic people, they make up a lot of America’s middle class that want results. If that had happened, then I think we would be talking about a different post-election analysis. And it didn’t happen. And I think the common denominator is a lot of people felt unheard. They felt unheard on the Iran war. They felt unheard on the economy.
And when you look at maybe the intersection of globalism and neoconservatism, part of it was summed up in the World Trade Organization and the idea that economic interdependence and free trade would somehow make us better off. You know, Ross Perot saw through that, and he said you’re going to see a giant sucking sound of our jobs leaving our economy. And yeah, cheaper stuff’s good. I’m a Frédéric Bastiat fan, the candle makers’ petition. Awesome. But the reality is we’re not competing against companies. We’re competing against foreign governments. And the right way to counter China and others isn’t to ignore the fact that they are players in this market. And it’s also not to become more like China and have state-sponsored capitalism. I think America First, though, does say we are going to make sure that our companies aren’t left defenseless against, you know, foreign rivals, that they do have a chance to pursue their American dream in the United States and not have their intellectual property stolen and monetized by a foreign government, that their markets aren’t undercut from them because a foreign government decides to subsidize and dump and distort the market. And that really has hollowed out our middle class in the United States. And that’s a big part of what inspired the Make America Great Again movement, that Donald Trump was able to cobble together this coalition in the first place.
But, you know, kind of the pendulum going the other way, there’s been a thing that’s undermined it, in the sense that you can’t have predictable capital formation in markets with some of the tariffs. And I think that’s the question: how do we calibrate that in this election? Border security, you know, we have to have a secure border. And we do right now. But can we do that in a way that’s consistent with our way of life and our values? And I think we have to deliver on that. I think that’s one of the things that people felt unheard about.
And when it comes to wars, you know, I don’t think the right answer… Look, I’m a former Army Ranger. I’m not an isolationist, but I don’t think we have to get involved in all the wars that we’re invited to, and we certainly don’t need to seek out extra ones. Right? And unfortunately, that’s been, you know, the post-Cold War America. I think we have to recognize that we are a de facto empire. You know, we didn’t seek to be an empire in a lot of cases. But when you look at, in the wake of World War II, we were the real economy standing, and we had a real ideological rival in the Soviet Socialist Republic.
I mean, I was fortunate to have joined the military while the Cold War was still going on. I got sent to Germany in 1989. By the time I arrived, early 1989, I was there when, in Bad Tölz, Germany, training with 10th Special Forces Group in the mountains in southern Germany, this E‑7 steps up and says, right, to stay down. It’s going to be one of the most famous days in history. Ninth of November, 1989. Right? Wow. That’s today. It’s a pretty bold intro to your talk. You know, he’s like, no, the Berlin Wall just came down. So somebody and I went there, and we got to go through Checkpoint Charlie, go past the still-secure border but not being blocked.
So we go there. We have still one of the nicest meals I’ve ever had in my life. My first one ever with, like, you know, white linen tablecloths and violins. And they top your wine off the minute you take a sip. It was pretty impressive. It was like over a month’s wages for an East German. But as an E‑3 in the Army, I could afford it pretty easily. Right? So that was my first recognition of comparative economics with currency. Right? So you look at currency valuations, sound money is truly essential to defending freedom.
But later that weekend, we were in the district that’s just like Times Square for Berlin, and I met people there, first hours across the border. They were like, is it like this everywhere? And I thought they meant, you know, big city versus small town. I’m from a smaller town. And they said, no, the stores are open at night and there’s fresh milk. So I’m trying to explain a 7‑Eleven. He goes, no, like, everyone can go in and there’s always stuff on the shelves. I’m like, yeah, they want everyone to go, and so they sell more stuff. He’s like, well then how are there things on the shelf? And I’m like, buddy, you know, you’ve clearly been lied to. He’s like, yeah, we clearly have. They told us that you only had a couple of blocks for show, like we did. All right.
And I think about Reagan saying, you know, freedom’s never more than one generation away from extinction. And today I serve with members of Congress who describe themselves as socialists. So, you know, I think for sure America First is not a socialist idea. You know, socialism and subsidies aren’t going to deal with the affordability crisis. Freedom and free markets are.
And so, if you think about the ideas in the wake of Vietnam, we had this idea, some called it the Powell Doctrine, that before we commit to a war, we understand what’s our exit strategy. And I say even before that, what is the mission, and what would it take to accomplish it? Is that a price we’re willing to pay? You count the cost. And if you can’t define the mission, well, then what are you doing? Then the Constitution lays out in Article I, and as clarified in Federalist 69, that Congress authorizes the wars, wars of choice anyway. I mean, there’s a duty for the president to respond to an imminent threat. The War Powers Act clarified that duty and said, not only do you have a duty to do it, you have 60 days to even get to Congress to work on an authorization. That’s largely been honored in the breach rather than the observance. But, you know, that was a framework that I think we tried to lay out, is to say, yeah, and why? I just think pragmatically, as a former soldier, if you could ask people to deploy, to fight, to wage war on behalf of the nation, at least the representatives could vote. Right?
So in earlier days, you know, if you look back, King David got into trouble because he was back hanging out at the palace instead of on the front fighting the battle. And it’s easy to keep kind of a constant state of war when the senior leaders for the countries are safe and prosperous, when the soldiers are bearing the burden. So I think on this whole host of things, not just for the average American, but for a lot of veterans, they feel unheard. You see veteran suicides, you know, 20-plus a day still, tragically. You think of the cost of war. And a lot of people went and voted because the cost of gas was higher. But I think one of the best metrics for the cost of war in this century: if you go back 20 years ago, we were spending about $25 billion a year on the VA. And of course, we have a burden to care for our veterans. They’ve made great sacrifices for our country, and we owe it to care for them as a consequence of their service. But today we spend over $400 billion a year. That’s a cost that continues to go on well after the war. And of course, there’s a human cost there, in our country and in others.
So I think people are tired of pretending that that can be distilled down to a pejorative. And it’s time to have the debate. I think the neoconservatives know they will lose the debate on the facts and certainly with the public sentiment. But if this election makes anything clear, it’s that the voters feel unheard and they’re tired of the status quo that has been dominated for this century, at least in the wake of the Cold War, by neoconservatives and globalists. I think the answer is to return to realpolitik, the America First version of it, that puts America’s resources as America’s priority. And in the wake of that, I’d say it’s a good time to keep calm and defend freedom.
So, thanks to you guys for being a great voice for doing all of that, and for the opportunity to share my thoughts. God bless you all.