In a strange chapter of his new book, Communion, Vice President JD Vance laments how the “technocratic cost-benefit analysis” of economics can “crowd out your sense of right and wrong.”
Vance recalls how, during a law school seminar he attended, economic reasoning was used to debate whether chattel slavery had damaged the Southern economy or instead provided output fueling the Northern states’ growth.
To Vance, that discussion exemplified an economic discipline so absorbed by efficiency and output considerations that it could only examine an obvious moral abomination as though the decisive question were whether it raised GDP. He dubs this ostensible moral apathy the “hallmark of the dismal science.”