On Nov. 3, 2006, Miami-Dade police officers brought a drug detection dog to the front door of the home of Joelis Jardines without a warrant. The dog alerted to the smell of narcotics. The officers then applied for a search warrant and discovered that marijuana was being grown inside the home. The Supreme Court of Florida held that the dog’s warrantless “sniff test” constituted a “search” for purposes of the Fourth Amendment and quashed the conviction. Florida successfully petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case. Cato’s brief supports Jardines but argues more broadly that the case is an ideal opportunity for the Court to revise Fourth Amendment search-and-seizure doctrine altogether. Instead of determining whether a person has “reasonable expectations of privacy,” courts should examine whether a “search” has occurred by seeing if police accessed something that was hidden from plain view. When a person has relied on physics—concealing something, muffling sounds, etc.—and the law to arrange for something to be hidden, the Fourth Amendment and the Court should back those privacy-protective arrangements, breaching them only when there is probable cause and a warrant (or some exception to the warrant requirement). To hold otherwise would be to allow the government to invade privacy using not just drug-sniffing dogs but evermore sophisticated technology in ways the Framers anticipated and foreclosed.
Featuring the author Angus Deaton, Dwight D. Eisenhower Professor of Economic and International Affairs, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs & Economics Department, Princeton University; with comments by Charles Kenny, Senior Fellow, Center for Global Development; moderated by Ian Vasquez, Director, Center for Global Liberty and Prosperity, Cato Institute.
- Legal Briefs
- Cato Handbook for Policymakers
- Cato Journal
- Cato's Letter
- Cato's Letters
- Cato Papers on Public Policy
- Cato Policy Report
- Cato State Legislative Guide
- Cracking the Books
- Economic Freedom of the States of India
- Economic Freedom of the World
- Public Comments
- Supreme Court Review
Michael F. Cannon’s testimony before the House Judiciary Committee on presidential powers is cited on KLIF AM Radio
December 4, 2013
Michael F. Cannon’s testimony before the House Judiciary Committee on presidential powers is cited on FOX’s America’s Newsroom
December 4, 2013
Latest CommentaryIn the May 2013 issue of Teen Ink, a magazine I read regularly, Brooklyn teenager Isheta Khanom writes of “Being Muslim”: “People are...
The 2008-2009 financial crisis and Great Recession have vastly increased the power and scope of the Federal Reserve, and radically changed the financial landscape. This new ebook examines those changes and considers how the links between money, markets, and government may evolve in the future.