Some Perspective on the President’s Budget Request

The White House has been spinning reporters all day with the claim that the new budget holds non-defense spending down, and in some cases even cuts some domestic spending from 2006 budget levels. 

To test the claim, I’ve compiled below the proposed fiscal 2008 inflation-adjusted growth rates for spending in the non-defense Cabinet-level agencies compared to the 2006 budget:

Real Proposed Change in 2008 Non-Defense Cabinet-Level Agency Budget vs. 2006 Budget Level
   
Agriculture -9.2%
Commerce 5.9%
Education -40.2%
Energy 6.1%
Health and Human Services 8.5%
Housing and Urban Development -0.2%
Interior 10.8%
Justice -1.7%
Labor 15.6%
Transportation 6.3%
Treasury 7.7%
Veterans Affairs 13.8%
EPA -10.9%
Total
4.1%

All told, there are five agencies that receive a cut in real dollars: Agriculture, Education, HUD, Justice, and the Environmental Protection Agency. Yet even by the White House’s own numbers, all of these programs combined will still grow beyond the 2006 levels by 4 percentage points above inflation. 

Still, we need to wonder: What does this standard really tell us? 

Not much. The 2006 budget levels were already bloated after a six-year Republican spending spree. What’s actually interesting to see is how much these agencies would grow — after adjusting for inflation and assuming Congress rubber-stamps the president’s new budget — when compared to budget levels on the day Bush assumed office: 

Real Proposed Change in 2008 Non-Defense Cabinet-Level Agency Budget vs. 2001 Budget Level
   
Agriculture 8.0%
Commerce 16.8%
Education 36.2%
Energy 10.7%
Health and Human Services 35.6%
Housing and Urban Development 8.3%
Interior 12.0%
Justice 7.7%
Labor 8.8%
Transportation 12.4%
Treasury 11.7%
Veterans Affairs 52.7%
EPA -12.8%
Total
22.4%

To put it another way: Bush’s new budget still does next to nothing to strip away most of the massive budget increases in domestic programs he signed into law since 2001. It’s the fiscal equivalent of a recovering alcoholic patting himself on the back for merely drinking six beers a day instead of eight.