Cato on Facebook
Cato on Twitter
Cato on YouTube
Cato RSS1000 Massachusetts Ave, NW
Washington, DC 20001-5403
Phone (202) 842 0200
Fax (202) 842 3490
Contact Us
November 4, 1996
Policy Analysis no. 262
Beyond the Communications Decency Act: Constitutional Lessons of the Internet
by Solveig Bernstein
Solveig Bernstein is assistant director of telecommunications and technology studies at the Cato Institute.
Solveig Bernstein is assistant director of telecommunications and technology studies at the Cato Institute.
Published on November 4, 1996
PRINT PAGE
CITE THIS
Share with your friends:
On February 8, 1996, the Communications Decency Act was enacted into law. The law criminalizes the use of any computer network to display "indecent" material, unless the content provider uses an "effective" method to restrict access to that material to anyone under the age of 18. But there is no affordable, effective way for nonprofit or low-profit speakers to restrict children's access to such a broad, ill-defined category of material. Thus, the statute effectively bans much speech from the Internet and other networks. The Internet promised the ordinary citizen a low-cost method of reaching an audience beyond immediate family, friends, and neighbors. Legislation like the CDA betrays that hope and is clearly unconstitutional.
No regulation of computer network indecency, however carefully tailored, should pass constitutional scrutiny. First, no legislator has been able to define indecency coherently. Such regulation is inherently unfair, especially as applied to spontaneous, casual speech of the sort that the Internet facilitates between unsophisticated and noncommercial speakers. Second, government cannot legitimately claim that it has any interest in content control, when civil society has solved the perceived problem on its own. Here, private sector solutions include both software filters that parents can use to screen out offensive material and Internet service providers who provide access only to child-safe materials.
View this Policy Analysis in HTML
Share with your friends:
© 2009 The Cato Institute
Please send comments to webmaster
The Fallacy Of Campaign Finance Reform
This book takes a penetrating look into the premises and consequences of the long crusade against big money in politics.
Opinion and Commentary
Studies
- The Durable Internet: Preserving Network Neutrality without Regulation
- Broadcast Localism and the Lessons of the Fairness Doctrine
- Internet Privacy and Self-Regulation: Lessons from the Porn Wars
- Chilling the Internet? Lessons from FCC Regulation of Radio Broadcasting
- New Age Comstockery: Exon vs. the Internet
Daily Podcasts
Events
- In Search of Jefferson's Moose: Notes on the State of Cyberspace
- Future Imperfect: Technology and Freedom in an Uncertain World
- FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life, McCain v. Wisconsin Right to Life, Does the First Amendment Protect Political Speech?
- The Dangers of Disclosure: The Unintended Consequences of Campaign Regulations for Free Speech and Privacy
- A Skeptical Look at Grassroots Lobbying Disclosure
Feeds for Cato events: