![Media Name: scr-04.jpg](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/serial_cover_phone/public/serials/covers/scr-04.jpg?itok=ZCvhLfXi) 

# 2003–2004 

Edited by [Mark Moller](https://www.cato.org/people/mark-moller) 

The 2003–2004 edition of the *Cato Supreme Court Review* features a special 96-page symposium on the Constitution during wartime. It also includes essays by Walter Dellinger on economic rights and Erik Jaffe on McCain-Feingold.

##### Foreword 

#### [Can Law This Uncertain Be Called Law? ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/can-law-uncertain-be-called-law)

By [Roger Pilon](https://www.cato.org/people/roger-pilon) 

##### Introduction 

#### [Introduction ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/introduction)

By [Mark Moller](https://www.cato.org/people/mark-moller) 

##### Annual B. Kenneth Simon Lecture 

#### [The Indivisibility of Economic Rights and Personal Liberty ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/indivisibility-economic-rights-personal-liberty)

By Walter Dellinger 

##### Symposium: The Constitution at War 

#### [Power and Liberty in Wartime ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/power-liberty-wartime)

By [Tim Lynch](https://www.cato.org/people/tim-lynch) 

#### [Executive and Judicial Overreaction in the Guantanamo Cases ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/executive-judicial-overreaction-guantanamo-cases)

By Neal K. Katyal 

#### [Art and the Constitution: The Supreme Court and the Rise of the Impressionist School of Constitutional Interpretation ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/art-constitution-supreme-court-rise-impressionist-school)

By Jonathan Turley 

##### Federalism 

#### [Making a Federal Case Out of It: *Sabri v. United States* and the Constitution of Leviathan ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/making-federal-case-out-it-sabri-v-united-states-constitution)

By Gary Lawson 

#### [*Tennessee v. Lane*: How Illegitimate Power Negated Non-Existent Immunity](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/tennessee-v-lane-how-illegitimate-power-negated-non-existent-immunity)

By [Robert A. Levy](https://www.cato.org/people/robert-levy) 

##### Separation of Powers 

#### [The Cheney Decision ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/cheney-decision)

By Vikram David Amar 

#### [Old Puzzles, Puzzling Answers: The Alien Tort Statute and Federal Common Law in *Sosa v. Alvarez Machain*](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/old-puzzles-puzzling-answers-alien-tort-statute-federal-common-law)

By [Mark Moller](https://www.cato.org/people/mark-moller) 

##### Freedom of Speech 

#### [*McConnell v. FEC*: Rationing Speech to Prevent ‘Undue’ Influence](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/mcconnell-v-fec-rationing-speech-prevent-undue-influence)

By Erik Jaffe 

#### [*Ashcroft v. ACLU II*: The Beat Goes On](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/ashcroft-v-aclu-ii-beat-goes)

By [Robert Corn-Revere](https://www.cato.org/people/robert-corn-revere) 

##### Religious Liberty and the State 

#### [Function Follows Form: *Locke v. Davey’s* Unnecessary Parsing ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/function-follows-form-locke-v-daveys-unnecessary-parsing)

By Susanna Dokupil 

##### Criminal Law 

#### [A Bird Called Hiibel: The Criminalization of Silence ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/bird-called-hiibel-criminalization-silence)

By M. Christine Klein 

#### [The Pringle Case’s New Notion of Probable Cause: An Assault on *Di Re* and the Fourth Amendment ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/pringle-cases-new-notion-probable-cause-assault-di-re-fourth)

By Tracey Maclin 

#### [The Confrontation Clause Re-Rooted and Transformed ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/confrontation-clause-re-rooted-transformed)

By Richard D. Friedman 

##### Missed Opportunities 

#### [A Fistful of Denial: The Supreme Court Takes a Pass on Commerce Clause Challenges to Environmental Laws ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/fistful-denial-supreme-court-takes-pass-commerce-clause-challenges)

By John C. Eastman 

##### Coming Up 

#### [The Upcoming 2004 ](/supreme-court-review/2003-2004/upcoming-2004)

By Thomas C. Goldstein 

##### Latest Issues 

[![2025/2026 Supreme Court Review Cover](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/serial_cover_phone/public/2026-09/2025-2026-supreme-court-review-cover.jpg?itok=RzbKKNHe)](https://www.cato.org/supreme-court-review/2025-2026) 

[2025–2026](/supreme-court-review/2025-2026)

[![Cato Supreme Court Review: 2024-2025 cover](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/serial_cover_phone/public/2025-09/cato-supreme-court-review-cover.png?itok=7_lUd18p)](https://www.cato.org/supreme-court-review/2024-2025) 

[2024–2025](/supreme-court-review/2024-2025)

[![Cato Supreme Court Review 2023-2024 Cover](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/serial_cover_phone/public/2024-09/2023-2024-Supreme-Court-Review-cover.jpg?itok=JTojGUMg)](https://www.cato.org/supreme-court-review/2023-2024) 

[2023–2024](/supreme-court-review/2023-2024)

[![Cato Supreme Court Review - 2022-2023 Cover](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/serial_cover_phone/public/2023-09/supreme-court-review-2022-23-cover.png?itok=C0epFfyc)](https://www.cato.org/supreme-court-review/2022-2023) 

[2022–2023](/supreme-court-review/2022-2023)