

# Cato Expert: Restoring Juries’ Role in Sentencing Will Restore Mercy 

A jury that is curated by prosecutors, buffeted by judges, and kept ignorant of consequences cannot be the doer of justice and the reservoir of mercy.

January 12, 2026 • News Releases 

Recently, Judges Stephanos Bibas and Richard Sullivan discussed the benefits of having more informed and empowered juries at a seminar titled “Mercy, Retribution, and the Sentencing Judge.”

After the seminar, the Director of the Cato Institute’s Project on Criminal Justice, [Matthew Cavedon](https://url.avanan.click/v2/r01/___https://zwly9k6z.r.us-east-1.awstrack.me/L0/https:%2A2F%2A2Fwww.cato.org%2A2Fpeople%2A2Fmatthew-cavedon/1/0100019bb2b64295-40d22a9c-9e67-422c-a98e-dd6c77d72581-000000/cx6QXNBUouWcrmTxyMIBZrZOI08=460___.YXAzOmNhdG9pbnN0aXR1dGU6YTpvOjAxNjlkM2ZmZDY5M2YyNDkzMmRkODgzMGNiMGZkNTI4Ojc6YzYzMDplODlmYzhmZjY2MzNmNzM0Nzg1NjE3NGFmMzcyMGFkMDgyOGE0OWEzN2ZhZDE0MjVmYjJiYjMwZmZhZTUyNjhlOmg6VDpO), wrote a new [blog post](https://url.avanan.click/v2/r01/___https://zwly9k6z.r.us-east-1.awstrack.me/L0/https:%2A2F%2A2Fwww.cato.org%2A2Fblog%2A2Frecovering-mercy-restoring-jury-power-lessons-judges-bibas-sullivan/1/0100019bb2b64295-40d22a9c-9e67-422c-a98e-dd6c77d72581-000000/Qef6u8C2YzW8Lb_yZddjOX3czt4=460___.YXAzOmNhdG9pbnN0aXR1dGU6YTpvOjAxNjlkM2ZmZDY5M2YyNDkzMmRkODgzMGNiMGZkNTI4Ojc6NTYyZjo0NTEwYjE1YzQzYjZlNTY0NjA4NGZhMDFlYTUwNWYxNzg2Y2MxNDYzNmY2YjkzN2VlYTRmMmFiYzVjMTU3NWYyOmg6VDpO) discussing how restoring the proper role of juries will help restore mercy in our criminal justice system, writing:

> *“A jury that is curated by prosecutors, buffeted by judges, and kept ignorant of consequences cannot be the doer of justice and the reservoir of mercy. It is reduced to being a mere functionary, instead of embodying government by the people.*
> 
> *That degradation ignores what colonial Americans understood: mechanistic justice is no justice at all. Justice without mercy is incomplete, and the community’s conscience, carried by 12 ordinary jurors, deserves a central place in sentencing.”*

To speak with Cavedon further on the proper role of juries, contact [Christopher Tarvardian](mailto:ctarvardian@cato.org).

[![Creative Commons License](/build/cato_2020/images/creative-commons.svg)](http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/) 
This work is licensed under a [Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/).