# Multimedia 

Multimedia 

---

- [Podcasts](/podcasts)
- [Cato Video](/multimedia/cato-video)
- [Video Series](/search/category/video-series)
- [Events](/multimedia/events)

Download:

[ 

Audio 

](https://feeds.acast.com/public/streams/6ad8dc9e5de627c5404c44ef/episodes/6aeb644815384211771bbcca.mp3) 

#### Transcript 

*This transcript was generated using AI automation and may contain minor formatting or transcription errors. Please refer to the original audio to verify specific quotes or context.*

The Economics of It: The Economics of Main Street Millionaires

**Host:** Ryan Bourne **Guests:** Owen Zidar and Eric Zwick

**Ryan Bourne:** I’m Ryan Bourne and this is The Economics of It. Today’s episode is the economics of Main Street millionaires, with guests Owen Zidar and Eric Zwick.

When Americans picture the very rich, they typically imagine tech billionaires, Wall Street financiers and celebrities. But that focus misses a much larger, quieter class: the wealthy owners of businesses like car dealerships, medical practices, HVAC firms and regional distributors. There are roughly three million private business owners worth at least five million dollars each in this country, and I think their fortunes are spread right across America. And that success, I think, tells us important stories about American capitalism, ranging from rags-to-riches stories of entrepreneurship in many cases, to tax advantages, political influence and protection from competition for others.

So who are America’s Main Street millionaires? How did they get rich? And what do they tell us about the health of the American dream?

My guests today are two academics who’ve undertaken novel, pathbreaking work to understand this underexplored cohort of Americans. Owen Zidar is a professor of economics and public affairs at Princeton University. And Eric Zwick is professor of economics and finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. They are the authors of the great new book, *The Everywhere Millionaire*. Gentlemen, welcome to The Economics of It.

**Owen Zidar:** It’s great to be here.

**Eric Zwick:** Thanks for having us.

**Ryan Bourne:** So there are many amazing stories of entrepreneurship in this book. Dick Portillo, the hot dog king of Chicago, famously went from running a $1,100 hot dog trailer to turning it into a company that he sold for almost a billion dollars. Now, Eric, that story might be very unusual in scale, but your book argues it’s not unusual in kind. So why don’t you tell us a bit about the wealth of this cohort of Main Street millionaires and what it reflects?

**Eric Zwick:** So Portillo’s story is very inspiring, but you might also worry that we’re just selecting on success stories there and telling one of the most amazing ones, this hot dog billionaire whom we found in the yacht data. He got rich enough to buy a yacht called Top Dog, selling a lot of hot dogs. But in our larger-scale administrative data work, we look at the population of 10 million entrepreneurs who start businesses. And there we’re not selecting on success. They’re just people who start businesses that have an employee. And we look at what happens to them over the subsequent decade. Even on average, they do better than a very similar worker, with about 10 percent more income on average. And of course, the right-tail outcomes are quite a bit better than that.

But if you add up all of the people who have net worth above five million, as you mentioned, these private business owners that we call everywhere millionaires, there are three million of them. And the typical one is self-made like Portillo, not inheriting a business, but instead starting one with maybe a little bit of financial capital, a little bit of savings, maybe some help from family, but building into a much more successful business over the course of their life cycle.

**Ryan Bourne:** So give us a sense of the scale of that wealth. How much wealth are we talking about that is owned by these people?

**Eric Zwick:** So you add that group of people, that three million, up, and they’re more than $50 trillion of net worth in 2022, which is the last Survey of Consumer Finances data where we can get estimates of the value of those businesses and their other holdings. Just for comparison, if you take the Forbes 400 from that year and add those folks up, the people we hear so much about when we hear about wealth in America, that’s a little over four trillion. So these are more than 10 times, 13 times the net worth, for this mainstream millionaire class.

**Ryan Bourne:** So individually, they’re not as wealthy as Elon, but collectively, they far surpass the wealth and potentially the influence that he has. So that’s an incredible untold story, really. And you came to this project, as I understand it, from work you were doing for the Treasury back in 2014, where you were looking at the more narrow question of how much tax business owners pay. So what did you see there in the data that led you to think there was a more interesting story here?

**Owen Zidar:** So initially, as you mentioned, the Treasury brought us in and they wanted us to figure out how to link these businesses to their owners so we could compute tax rates and evaluate different policies. And what emerged was this really fascinating picture that I think crystallized when we looked at the top 1% share. If you look at one of the most famous pictures in economics, it’s the share of income going to the top 1%. Thomas Piketty and Emmanuel Saez graphed it, and it’s U‑shaped in the 20th century. And if you do that same graph, but hold fixed how important pass-through income is, which are…

**Ryan Bourne:** So could you just define pass-through?

**Owen Zidar:** Yeah, so pass-throughs are businesses that are very typical for everywhere millionaires. Instead of facing the traditional corporate tax, like public companies, they have the profits and losses flow through to the owners directly. What’s really nice from a research perspective is that flow-through structure lets you follow the money and actually figure out who owns all of these companies. And if you take that famous graph and hold pass-through shares fixed for these private businesses, which are now most of business activity (in terms of the share of firms, it’s about half of employment and the majority of profits), about half of the growth in the top 1% share comes from the rise of pass-through income at the top.

**Ryan Bourne:** So talk to me a bit, Eric, about how you calculated this, because if you’ve got a big public company like Amazon, obviously they have a share price and we can use that to calculate Jeff Bezos’ billions. But when you’re talking about private businesses, it’s often quite unclear who owns the business. There’s not obviously public data that you can get that would allow you to calculate that wealth in the same way. So how did you go about constructing actual estimates of the wealth here?

**Eric Zwick:** So the advantage of working within this admin data environment, and the benefit of this historical change, which was the rise of these pass-through businesses, is that within the way tax returns get filed, for the business, you have a tax return. So from that business, there’s its income and losses, industry, rough geography, something like that. But because the taxes are on the owners instead of on the business, there’s a link between the owners and the businesses that allows you to say, okay, who are the owners? Who’s at the top of the income distribution earning a bunch of income from these businesses? And then link back through to the businesses. And using that business information, you can estimate the value of those businesses.

There is art in estimating the net worth of somebody using private business, and that then becomes a question also for tax authorities and others. The Survey of Consumer Finances asks these business owners what they think they could fetch if they sold the business. Some of them are quite optimistic. We have methods, basically adopting the best practices from financial investors that use market multiples, to try and guess, based on characteristics of these businesses, what they’re worth. There’s a range of uncertainty there for sure. You know how much income they’re distributing to their owners, so you have a sense that these folks are doing quite well, and you can guess whether they’re likely to be a mainstream millionaire, an everywhere millionaire that rich. But we don’t know the precise value. And in some sense, that’s in the eye of the beholder: what somebody is willing to buy the business for.

**Ryan Bourne:** So, Owen, add a bit of color to this for us. Because when we think of top wealth in the US, as I mentioned at the start, we tend to think of the billionaire classes. People tend to be geographically located in major cities on both coasts. But as I understand it, a lot of the wealth we’re talking about is from what look like run-of-the-mill, ordinary businesses across all parts of the country.

**Owen Zidar:** Yeah. So we in fact have a chapter, chapter two, devoted to taking a road trip across America, where we meet some of these people. In Mississippi, there’s someone who focuses on making seamless gutters, and it’s an enormously successful business. And we go to Oklahoma, go to basically any nice golf resort or lake town or mountain town and look at all the houses and ask who owns those homes. And we meet a ton of people who have, you know, a hundred million dollar business here, folks in Utah that you never heard of who have just enormous homes. And you could basically talk to anyone and say, do you know any stories of people who’ve done quite well? And you hear about people who have literally done seawalls or storing paper or removing snow from airports. And it’s just a lot of mundane stuff. But if you do it at scale, like cleaning windows at airports, a lot of these businesses are remarkably successful.

**Ryan Bourne:** I think that’s one of the things that I really took away from the book. A lot of these businesses aren’t people doing breakthrough innovations, totally new technologies. They’re often doing very well selling what looks like a fairly mundane product, but doing it well in a way that consumers really value. Now, some people would react to that and say it’s obscene to be able to get rich off these services, just ordinary businesses that anyone can do. But clearly the consumers think that they’re creating value, or they’ve been able to find a way of scaling the business in a way that many other competitors haven’t been able to.

**Eric Zwick:** So I totally agree. And it’s interesting to present this work and tell some of these stories, especially about people who are very successful in, say, fast casual dining, where it’s extremely competitive. They’ve been able to establish a brand, build a product, bring it to market amid McDonald’s, amid Wendy’s, and grow dramatically, such as Portillo’s, or, as we tell in another story generations later, Dave’s Hot Chicken kind of doing the same thing with hot chicken sandwiches. And these innovations that they have are not the Moderna vaccine. Nevertheless, they’re in big markets and consumer trends evolve and wax and wane. And they find a gap and they just run right through that gap and they deliver a product that people are willing to buy and willing to pay enough for, such that there’s a substantial profit margin there. And these people can make a lot of money. It looks easy ex post. Ex ante, there’s a lot of grind in it and there’s a lot of risk and uncertainty, I think, going into whether this is going to work. But it is a different take on capitalism, the value of incremental innovation. And that’s an important element of economic growth: these incremental innovations that we pay less attention to because they look kind of obvious. And so I think that’s one of the lessons from telling these stories. We like that counterpart to the big data, these stories we’re able to tell, because they make it really tangible what’s going on on the ground.

**Ryan Bourne:** And is that the typical story of one of these successful Main Street millionaires, that they become best in class at providing a service locally? They’ve made big profits from that, unexpected profits, they reinvest the profits. And over time, they’re able to scale their business, perhaps sell it off to a private equity firm eventually. Am I mischaracterizing it too much, or is that the kind of path most of them see?

**Owen Zidar:** That is quite common in many of the stories. Like Eric was saying on risk, one of the people that we talked to at the end of that road trip that I mentioned, Nancy Mueller, spent decades putting a business together. It started with a Christmas party where she made lots of frozen quiche by hand and slowly scaled that up. But even a decade or two in, she was very nervous about going under. There was one point when she said, look, I might even fold the business. And then she ended up getting some big accounts and pursued it. But she was reinvesting a lot and putting in a lot of time and effort. There is a great deal of risk and experimentation and improvement. So I do think that captures a good flavor of many of these businesses.

**Eric Zwick:** There’s a second category that I’ll add that I think, especially sitting here at Cato, we should definitely touch on, which is folks operating in industries where they’ve been able to erect barriers or pull up the drawbridge behind them a little bit, such that a lot of the profits and excess profits come less from being innovative and more from having been there first and written some laws that then help protect them. So we have a whole chapter on local market power, where we think about industries where you see these regulations generate a lot of mainstream millionaires: the auto dealers, the beer distributors, and then skilled services, such as realtors, dentists, doctors, and so on. And I think that’s another dimension of the story that deserves a fair amount of attention and conversation, because it changes how you think about those particular folks.

**Ryan Bourne:** So obviously a lot of interest in your book stems from the fact we’re having a public conversation about wealth inequality. That is, the gap between the amount of wealth held by the top 1% and the rest of society. Now, I can’t speak for everybody at Cato, but my own view of that debate has always been that it’s incredibly frustrating, because I care much more about how wealth has been obtained than about the absolute gap between rich and poor. If people have made a lot of wealth as a result of providing value, by creating new products, by scaling products, by finding ways of producing things more cheaply, then I’m fine with that. If they’ve obtained that wealth, on the other hand, by lobbying Congress or state and local governments for privileges, for means of blocking out potential competition, or from government-imposed licensing laws and cronyism, where government works with a business sector to restrict entry, then I care about it much more. So I mean, what’s your sense? Obviously there’s no perfect answer to this, but what’s your sense of the extent to which this cohort of individuals reflects value creation rather than value expropriation?

**Owen Zidar:** I think that’s a great question, and this tension between the creation and capture of rents is really key. And it’s a really hard question to answer well. So take doctors, for example. There’s no question there are many medical professionals who provide a ton of value. Giving people more quality life years is one of the most important and economically valuable things you can do. As a consumer, if you watch the show *The Pitt*, for example, people who are really hustling in an ER department and working around the clock, it’s really hard to say anything but thank you to them. That said, there are really substantial restrictions on entry for doctors. There are caps on the number of people who can train at residency programs. We’re much lower in the United States than peer countries in terms of doctors per capita. Health care costs a lot more. It really wreaks a lot of havoc in the labor market. There could be a lot more. Generally, if you take an economic view on inequality in a very simple way, in the market for doctors, if the price is too high, you want more supply. And that’s one natural way to lower the price and have things be more affordable. And so you could have nurses do more, you could have qualified immigrant doctors come in and really just try to have a lot more supply for medical services. And restrictions on that, which doctors, through various political campaigns, have been quite influential at maintaining, have prevented that. And a lot of us are paying the price through the cost of higher health care.

**Ryan Bourne:** Yeah, and those are all actual policies that Cato has been pushing, supply liberalizations, in our recent handbook on affordability. But unfortunately, there are some sectors that are riven with these types of government-granted privileges that do facilitate rent-seeking. You give some great examples in the book: the beer distributor has been the only game in town for decades, and a lot of state franchising laws when it comes to car dealerships. And I actually think car dealerships are an interesting example because it’s a nuanced story, isn’t it? There are some examples that you give which show that a particular business owner of a car dealership has provided value, because when perhaps they die or leave the business, the business’s fortunes completely turn, which suggests that they’re having a fairly big impact on value creation for the customer. But then you’ve got a lot of these laws that have been in place for decades that really do enrich car dealers at the expense of consumers, say, by preventing consumers from buying cars directly from the manufacturer.

**Eric Zwick:** Car dealers show up in a number of places in the book, in part because their presence at the top of the income and wealth distributions was one of the most surprising things to us, especially once we got into learning about the tax policy debate and how that evolves. We opened the book with the story of a $60 million wedding, called the Wedding of the Century, where the parents of the bride flew all the guests by private jet to Paris and rented out…

**Ryan Bourne:** The Palace of Versailles, right?

**Eric Zwick:** The Palace of Versailles. Not even for the wedding, but just for a party the night before, where they had makeup artists on deck to dress the guests up in period costume, somewhat unironically, I think, of the lost monarchy, because we know how that ended. But they were third-generation car dealers. And we see car dealers show up in the data as well. And I think the fact that they’re third generation is also informative about your earlier question about how big the rent piece is versus the self-made or growth piece. We can look at the share of people in the top 1% or 0.1% in this business owner class who made their businesses versus inherited them, as a rough proxy of this notion that maybe the rents or the protections have been there for a while and are being handed down across generations. We think about a quarter to a third of these top 1% or 0.1% millionaires inherited their businesses. It means the typical one is not; it’s self-made, bought it, or started from scratch. But it does mean there’s a substantial portion of the economy of these large businesses, like in the car dealer case, where these laws were initially put in place to protect the little guy, these little car dealers, from the big manufacturers, to give them some power to keep Henry Ford from dumping the wrong model onto them without any volition. Well, all of a sudden the car dealers have flipped the script. They don’t let manufacturers enter and sell directly to consumers. They don’t let manufacturers start new brands without going through the dealer network. And they have first-mover advantage to sell not just the cars but also warranty repairs, where they get these protective prices, and insurance and financing, where they make a lot of profits also because of being first there.

And I don’t think that is being particularly innovative generally, but even there we have some exceptions where a very enterprising person didn’t come up that way. Larry Miller from Utah started working in a parts department, and when the person he was working for wanted to give the business to his kids, Larry was like, screw you, I’m going to go buy one from somebody else who’s retiring. And he built this giant empire because he was so effective at scaling these businesses, and ended up buying a basketball team and many other businesses. So even there there’s a little bit of nuance, although I think on average the point is that there are barriers to entry, and probably that’s where we would expect some inefficient operation of assets, some excess profits, some room for improvement in terms of public policy letting new entrants come in. That’s where I land on that one.

**Ryan Bourne:** So if most of these mainstream millionaires aren’t dependent on inherited capital or large amounts of money or inheriting the business for their current wealth, what does explain it? What typical things that they’ve gone through, what formative experiences, help explain how they get to the positions that they do?

**Eric Zwick:** So one thing that we often see: first of all, the model that you might have heard of, go to Silicon Valley, move fast and break things, make an app and get rich in five seconds, that is not the model. It’s a slog of rolling up your sleeves for decades, maybe working in the industry first and building it slowly, reinvesting and having that compound over a long period of time. That is much more how a lot of these self-made founders have done it. And so the typical wealthy person is a little bit older, they’re in their 60s, because they’ve been spending decades either learning industry experience or moving around and taking some of their experiences and applying them to problems that they see in the marketplace. And that’s quite different from this go-to-Silicon-Valley, raise-a-bunch-of-money-and-create-some-software model. It’s stuff with your hands, often. It’s tactile and tangible, maybe unglamorous business.

**Ryan Bourne:** If I’m hearing you right, exposure to the industry, exposure to experience, seeing somebody run a business up close, that’s more important.

**Owen Zidar:** Yeah. So Larry Miller, for example, that Eric mentioned, he worked in the parts department and he learned every single part at Toyota and really understood the business and how it worked. He turned around the parts department of this dealership in Utah from 961st to first, because he was very sharp, worked hard and could really deliver a lot of value. And that experience gave him the ability to then say, okay, maybe I’m going to run a couple of these. And by the time he got passed over for the heirs of the business, he was running five of the dealerships. So as a worker, he really got a lot of entrepreneurial human capital. Other people, like Shahid Khan, he got rich off of car bumpers, but he was working, and then he started his own thing, and Toyota was an early client, and now he owns the Jacksonville Jaguars. So there are a lot of stories of getting your hands dirty, learning who the customers are, learning how the business actually operates, and then maybe getting lucky and being in a position to buy one of these companies, maybe when someone retires or when some opportunity opens up.

**Ryan Bourne:** So I think if somebody from the political left or the progressive left was reading your book, they would say, that’s all very well. There are some stories of genuine entrepreneurship here, but some of the data you show suggests that many of these businesses have seen big improvements in productivity, improvements in the amount of output relative to the inputs they’re putting in. And a lot of that has flowed to the owners of the businesses rather than the workers. Now, they might look at that and say, there’s a problem here. The workers need a rebalance of power. But let me put another hypothesis to you. If you look at CEO pay of public companies, it’s gone up dramatically over the past 30 to 40 years, and your own data seems to show in many instances that when an owner of a business dies unexpectedly, the business’s fortunes can change dramatically. Is this just all evidence that the relative value of having a decent owner is higher than it has been before? And so the returns to being an owner are higher because it’s a more difficult skill. Perhaps you’re navigating bigger global markets, you’re having to deal with a politically fraught environment at the moment. I mean, maybe these returns are just a market return to being a decent owner.

**Owen Zidar:** I think there’s a lot of resonance in your hypothesis. There’s a sense in which we situate these firms in a broader labor market where they’re competing with large companies to hire workers. And lower-skilled workers have faced a lot of headwinds over the years from the increase in availability of offshore labor, which, we show, it’s not just big companies that are able to take advantage of, it’s also the smaller companies. So as one example, if labor demand is not growing as much for those low-skill workers as it is for the folks at the top, you can see the tilt, the bias, towards the returns to the skill of those owner-managers at the top. And it’s consistent with what we see when one of those owner-managers prematurely passes away: the business can collapse if that person embodied within them an important part of the network, the know-how, the process, the connections to customers and so on. If that passes away too, that’s very hard to pass on. So I think the evidence does look like that.

At the same time, we have seen a proliferation of very unusual non-compete agreements for relatively low-skill workers at some of the businesses that are also owned by these everywhere millionaires. We tell the example of Jimmy John’s franchisers who are putting restrictions on sandwich artists. That is, they’re putting restrictions that say, if you work for us, you can’t go and work for a competitor within a certain period of time.

**Ryan Bourne:** That’s what a non-compete is. You can’t make a sandwich in another restaurant and sell it. You can’t practice your sandwich-making artistry in another Jimmy John’s or another sandwich-making restaurant within a three-mile radius. So I mean, that’s a pretty unusual extension of the notion of non-compete, which is really about protecting trade secrets, because I think butter and mayo, the bread, meat and the sandwich-making art can be practiced without losing that trade secret.

**Owen Zidar:** So I feel like there’s a little bit of resonance also with that progressive left story, that what’s going on in the labor market might be relevant for these firms as well. And the supply restrictions too that we were talking about before, some of the reason why the price is high is because of these barriers to entry. So I think it’s a nuanced take where you have to go industry by industry. Even within industries, you can tell stories that are more optimistic and others where you’re like, okay, this is actually because you’re not allowed to operate within a five-mile radius of this company, and that’s why that’s doing so well.

**Ryan Bourne:** Washington doesn’t love nuance at the moment, so I hope that we’re bringing it through in this discussion. I want to move on to the role of these business owners in politics, because they’re a small share of Americans overall, but actually play quite a disproportionate role both in Congress and also in state and local legislatures. So why don’t you just talk me through, Eric, first of all, how big is this cohort when it comes to actual elected politics?

**Eric Zwick:** So I think one thing that’s fun about the book is it has a little bit of a B story, where we’re learning about how policy is actually made and who has real control over the levers of power as we’re learning about the economy too. And one of the places we learn about this is by seeing how important these closely held business owners are in elected politics. About a quarter of federally elected politicians, we estimate, are private business owners, and that doesn’t even include the lawyers that are partners at law firms. And it is not just one side of the aisle or the other. If we go below the federal office to, say, local office, the share gets even higher. For mayors, it gets up to like 40% business owners. In part, these are part-time jobs. In part, these are low-paying jobs that require a certain kind of flexibility and other resources in order for people to do those jobs. And in part, because small business is such a venerated institution in society, running for office as a small business person can be a very attractive way to win an election. But it turns out they’re way overrepresented compared to the general population, where business owners that have employees are maybe a few percent, versus, like I said, a quarter of Congress.

**Ryan Bourne:** And I imagine this is a bit of a double-edged sword. Now, I don’t know if you can tell, but I’m from the UK, and I was looking at some statistics a few weeks ago and fewer than a third of members of parliament there have private sector experience outside of journalism and a few other things that I’d associate with industries that operate around politics. So they’ve got the opposite problem in many ways. This cohort of people, private sector employees, let alone business owners, are severely underrepresented. And as a result of that, quite often public policy treats businesses as something that resources can be extracted from rather than as an engine for economic growth and production that can actually generate tax revenues. But I get the sense from reading your book that you’re more worried in the other direction, that you think these business owners being disproportionately represented, particularly at the state and local level, can actually lead to the entrenchment of some of these unfair, supply-restricting policies that we spoke about.

**Eric Zwick:** That’s right. I mean, one thing at the federal level first, and then I’ll go to the state and local: we say there are everywhere millionaires in every congressional district, and that really can move what some of these policies end up looking like. And now that we’re aware of it, we see it all over the place. So I’m happy to go through specific tax policies, or we can hold that for a little bit later if you’d like.

**Ryan Bourne:** Please give us an example.

**Eric Zwick:** So for example, in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which was the biggest business tax cut in US history, broadly what it did is it lowered the corporate rate from 35 to 21. And one of the ways that they tried to pay for this was to broaden the base a little bit, and one of the base-broadening things was to say, if you borrow money, you normally can deduct that from your taxes as a business, but we’re going to put some limitations on that. And we saw auto dealers say, oh, this is going to destroy us, because we borrow a lot to put cars on our lot. And so when you see what actually passed, auto dealers got an exemption from this interest limitation. And that seemed a bit unnecessary, and that’s exactly the type of thing where these loopholes start coming about, and if you focus on where they’re coming from, you see them all over the place. For example, in 2025 there’s now a new deduction for taking out an auto loan. It’s kind of like the mortgage interest deduction, but for new cars. And these are the extra things that over time really pollute the tax code, and it would be much healthier to have a broader base and lower rates than to have these special carve-outs for what we call the loophole lobby.

**Owen Zidar:** And then at the state and local level, an example of this would be the proliferation of occupational licensing restrictions that raise the bar for people to enter occupations where in a lot of cases there maybe aren’t huge safety concerns, and that restrict the number of people who can provide certain services. These are mostly done at the state level, and there are guilds of people in these occupations that are really involved in the drafting of these rules and the tightening of these rules. One example we detail was the dentists trying to prevent non-dentists from practicing the art of tooth whitening, because they wanted you to have to go to the dentist to do that. And then they ended up losing a case in the Supreme Court, but for a long time, and in other states still, they were preventing people who weren’t dentists from providing tooth whitening services. And that just means that you have to go to the dentist, you pay more for those services, because there are fewer people who can do that.

**Ryan Bourne:** Teeth play a big role in this book. Everybody’s got teeth, it’s a huge market.

**Owen Zidar:** It’s a huge market. The dentists’ revenue is bigger than a bunch of the professional sports leagues combined, was one of the talking points from the dental lobbies, but it helps you understand why they’re surprisingly powerful.

**Ryan Bourne:** So one thing that you really document in the book is the growth of businesses that are described as pass-through businesses, and you detail how, over time since the 1980s, more and more businesses have been organizing themselves in this form rather than registering as corporations. So can you explain what that is, and how these pass-through businesses are actually a pretty powerful political lobby?

**Owen Zidar:** Absolutely. So in 1986, Reagan raised the burden on corporations a little bit and lowered the individual rate pretty materially, the individual income tax rate. And that made it, for the first time, more attractive to be a business owner in the form of a pass-through, where you face the individual income tax rather than the traditional corporate tax. And so we saw a lot of businesses form and some switch. And since then, this has really become the predominant type of business in America. And there are a huge number of examples of tax advantages that have come to this group. In the 2017 reform, for example, one of the most nefarious favors for this group is a 20% deduction: if you’re a private pass-through business owner that qualifies, instead of paying a 37% rate, you pay less than a 30% tax rate on your individual income. So you can say 20% of your profits, operating profits, are tax-exempt. Zero rate. And that’s a huge amount of money. And in 2025 they preserved this, at substantial expense, hundreds of billions of dollars over a decade. And most people on both sides of the aisle, when you look at the evidence of what these things have done, agree they basically haven’t really increased employment or investment. And so I think we need to be much more targeted and outcome-driven on what tax policies do. And this is a glaring example of the power of pass-throughs. Unlike other people, they’re saving 7%, and we’re not getting much for it.

**Ryan Bourne:** I mean, nobody would question Cato’s bona fides for being in favor of tax cuts. But actually, we ran a tax expenditure March Madness bracket, I think, a couple of years ago, looking at the worst tax expenditure, the worst deduction in the code, and the pass-through deduction from 2017 actually won that overall tournament. So we’re in full alignment on that. It’s not good tax policy if you want efficiency, and if you want equality between how different types of income are being taxed.

Now, if I were to summarize your book, I’d say ultimately it’s neither a celebration nor an indictment of this group. I think it highlights a lot of incredible entrepreneurial stories, but then does say that a sub-segment of this group actually obtains a lot of rents from these favors that are bestowed upon them by various layers of government, amounting to a bit of pulling away the ladder. So if you were to summarize the book overall, how optimistic did this research make you about the health of the American dream, of American capitalism more generally?

**Eric Zwick:** So our mission with this book, if there’s a mission, is definitely not to advocate for specific policies. It’s much more an eye-opening goal, to try and allow people to see the economy as it is, and especially this debate on income and wealth inequality as it is, as we see it with much better data than what’s been available before. We think this view of inequality and of income, wealth and prosperity in America has been badly distorted by limited data and a media environment that tends to amplify a small number of stories. And so when you step back and have that much wider view, that panoramic view, there is actually a lot of good news about the American dream that we don’t think gets a lot of attention. There are many paths to the top that remain open. Even in the rent-heavy industries where you have these fat cat incumbents, they’re underperforming their duties and they’re creating massive opportunities for people to try and enter, but it’s hard to do so. If you can figure out how to do it, I think that also creates opportunities where this kind of rebirth of capitalist systems can operate, and I’m hopeful for that vision of things.

At the same time, we say, here are a bunch of problems that seeing the world this way makes you realize and appreciate. If you want to solve policy problems, you need to understand them first. And that’s where we want to leave things with the book, and then engage in the policy debate and try to be as helpful as we can be.

**Ryan Bourne:** Now, I think from a Cato perspective, it’s really useful on three fronts. First is highlighting the power of entrepreneurship and the role that entrepreneurship plays. Secondly is correcting a lot of those misconceptions about the nature of wealth inequality. And I think the third one, which perhaps we haven’t talked about as much, but which is certainly relevant with discussions at the moment of wealth taxes and things like that, is just reminding people that when you talk about wealth, in many respects you’re talking about a lot of capital that’s tied up in very productive business assets. And if you’re forcing people to pay an annual charge on that, you’re inevitably going to disrupt many of those businesses as they exist.

But I’m afraid that’s all we’ve got time for. Thank you so much for coming into the studio and for all of your incredible work on this, Owen and Eric.

**Owen Zidar:** Thanks for having us.

**Eric Zwick:** Thank you for having us, Ryan.

**Ryan Bourne:** That’s all for today’s episode of The Economics of It, a production of the Cato Institute dedicated to advancing individual liberty, limited government, free markets and peace. Don’t forget to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. I’m Ryan Bourne, until next Thursday, goodbye.

The Economics of It • November 5, 2026 

# The Economics of Main Street Millionaires 

Who are the rich in America? Tech billionaires and Wall Street financiers dominate the headlines, but roughly three million private-business owners are worth at least $5 million each, scattered right across the country.

Economists Eric Zwick and Owen Zidar, the authors of *The Everywhere Millionaire,* join host Ryan Bourne to explain who these “Main Street Millionaires” are, how they got rich, and what their stories tell us about the health of the American Dream.

[Buy the book here](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1250378508?tag=catoinstitute-20)

**More on this topic:**

- Angus Deaton Inadvertently Shows Why We Shouldn’t Care about Economic Inequality Stats: [https://​www​.cato​.org/​c​o​m​m​e​n​t​a​r​y​/​a​n​g​u​s​-​d​e​a​t​o​n​-​i​n​a​d​v​e​r​t​e​n​t​l​y​-​s​h​o​w​s​-​w​h​y​-​w​e​-​s​h​o​u​l​d​n​t​-​c​a​r​e​-​a​b​o​u​t​-​e​c​o​n​o​m​i​c​-​i​n​e​q​u​a​l​i​t​y​-​stats](https://www.cato.org/commentary/angus-deaton-inadvertently-shows-why-we-shouldnt-care-about-economic-inequality-stats)
- Failures of Wealth Taxation: [https://​www​.cato​.org/​p​o​l​i​c​y​-​a​n​a​l​y​s​i​s​/​f​a​i​l​u​r​e​s​-​w​e​a​l​t​h​-​t​a​x​ation](https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/failures-wealth-taxation)
- Exploring Wealth Inequality: [https://​www​.cato​.org/​p​o​l​i​c​y​-​a​n​a​l​y​s​i​s​/​e​x​p​l​o​r​i​n​g​-​w​e​a​l​t​h​-​i​n​e​q​u​ality](https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/exploring-wealth-inequality)

Host &amp; Producer: Ryan Bourne 
Senior Producer: Barbara Galletti 
Video Editor: Lena Popilieva 
Audio Engineer: Sedona LaMarre 
Director of Photography: Darren Walker 
Assistant Producer: Nathan Miller 
Motion Graphics: Jonathan Fields 
Original Music: Cecil Sherman 
Executive Producer: Kristina Kendall

[![Creative Commons License](/build/cato_2020/images/creative-commons.svg)](http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/) 
This work is licensed under a [Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/). 

##### Featuring 

##### Eric Zwick 

Booth School of Business, University of Chicago

##### Owen Zidar 

Princeton University

[![Ryan Bourne](/sites/cato.org/files/styles/author_picture/public/2021-01/Ryan%20Bourne.jpg?itok=nv8-2r7d)](/people/ryan-bourne) 

##### [Ryan Bourne](/people/ryan-bourne)

R. Evan Scharf Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics, Cato Institute

[ 

](https://x.com/MrRBourne) [ 

](mailto:rbourne@cato.org)