Tag: police misconduct; police brutality

Police Misconduct — The Worst Case in November

Over at Cato’s Police Misconduct web site, we have identified the worst case for the month of November.  It involved several officers with the San Antonio Police Department (SAPD).

Here’s what reportedly happened.  SAPD police were hunting for a suspect on drugs and weapons charges.  In a case of mistaken identity, officers swarmed on poor Roger Carlos.  Mr. Carlos had done nothing wrong.  He was apparently just standing in the wrong place at the wrong time.  And even though Mr. Carlos complied with the police commands, to get on the ground and to not resist arrest, they just kept hitting him over and over again.

Mr. Carlos’s wife, Ronnie, still can’t believe what has happened to her husband.  The couple has three boys under the age of ten–but their father is now paralyzed from the chest down.  Doctors are also concerned that Mr. Carlos may have difficulty breathing down the road.  The medical bills for multiple surgeries are enormous.

After reviewing the case, a police discipline board recommended 15-day suspensions for three officers involved.  The Police Chief, William McManus, thought that recommendation was wrong.  He shortened each of the suspensions to five days.

Image result for roger carlos san antonio

Police Misconduct — The Worst Case in August

Over at Cato’s Police Misconduct web site, we have selected the worst case for the month of August.  This one goes to the City of Phoenix and its police agent, Kevin McGowan.

Here’s the background.  Patrick D’Labik, age 18, admits that he ran away from the police.  He ran because he said he had a bag of marijuana in his pocket and he didn’t want to go to jail.  Phoenix police officer Kevin McGowan caught up with D’Labik in a convenience store and the store had security cameras that captured the encounter.  Officer McGowan has his gun pointed at D’Labik, who was on his phone with his father, but who then quickly raises his hands in surrender.  As D’Labik is getting on the ground, Officer McGowan kicks him.  The force was so great that several teeth are knocked out.

In response to a complaint about excessive force, police commanders review the security camera footage and conclude the kick was unjustifiable.  McGowan loses his job with the police department.

But wait, Officer McGowan is now back on the force, patrolling the streets of Phoenix.  Turns out his termination was overturned by the Civil Service Board.

Here is security footage from the store:

Police Misconduct: The Worst Case in November

Over at Cato’s Police Misconduct Reporting Project, we have named the worst case for the month of November. It was the repeated, forced cavity search of two young men—in separate incidents—in New Mexico. 

The first victim, David Eckert, was pulled over by police for failing to make a complete stop at a stop sign. After a police K-9 who was uncertified for drug searches indicated the presence of marijuana, the officers told a judge that the victim appeared to be “clenching his buttocks” and requested a body cavity search warrant, which the judge granted. The officers took Eckert to a local hospital and requested that doctors perform the search, but the hospital doctors refused. The cops then took Eckert to a second hospital, in a neighboring county that was not covered by the warrant, where they found doctors willing to perform the search.

First, the doctors took an x-ray of Eckert’s abdomen, which showed no hidden drugs. Next, they forcibly probed Eckert’s anus with their fingers, which again uncovered no drugs. Undeterred, the doctors inserted an enema and forced Eckert to defecate in front of the officers: again, no drugs. The enema search was repeated twice, and still no drugs were found. Another x-ray was taken: no drugs. To cap off Eckert’s nightmare ordeal, the officers had the doctors sedate him and perform a colonoscopy, probing his anus, colon, rectum, and large intestines. No drugs found.  All of this was done against Eckert’s protest, in a county not covered by the search warrant, with part of the search done after the warrant had expired.

The second victim, Timothy Young, was brutalized in a similar manner after he was pulled over for failing to signal before making a turn, and after another marijuana indication by the same non-certified police dog. He was taken to the same hospital as Eckert and subjected to similar searching methods against his protests.

Cato’s Police Misconduct website often reports instances of police rape and sexual misconduct. In those cases, the offending officers typically do not contend that they have the legal right to abuse their victims’ bodies and are typically punished for their crime, even if often more lightly than others would be punished. Cases like this are entirely different. These cases show that officers can drum up warrants—for a dog’s bark and a perceived “clench”—to repeatedly and forcefully penetrate the depths of the human body for hours on end, and still think they have the power and lawful authority to repeat the process. Even worse, the futile, repeated nature of the searches seriously calls into doubt whether the officers were actually searching for drugs or just torturing the victims under the banner of law enforcement.

Police Misconduct — The Worst Case in October

Over at Cato’s Police Misconduct web site, we’ve selected the worst case for October:

So for October, it was Atlantic City Police Officer Sterling Wheaton. Recall that David Castellani had exchanged words with police outside a casino. Those officers took Castellani to the ground. Officer Wheaton then arrives on the scene and he immediately releases his dog to attack Castellani, who is still on the ground. The dog proceeds to bite Castellani’s head and neck.

The runner up goes to the Houston police officer who raped a handcuffed woman in the backseat of his patrol car. Responding to a fender bender, officer Adan Carranza handcuffed and arrested the victim and then waited for the other drivers involved in the accident to leave. The victim said Carranza, wearing his gun and badge, then raped her in the back of the patrol car before driving her to jail for a reckless driving charge. DNA evidence from the victim and back seat confirm the allegations, and Carranza has pled guilty—but only to attempted sexual assault. Carranza’s lawyer is hopeful his client will be paroled after only two or three years of his ten year sentence, of which he could serve as little as six months if a judge agrees to “shock probation.” One has to wonder how many rapists get that kind of deal.

Police Misconduct — The Worst Case in September

Over at Cato’s Police Misconduct web page, where we track misconduct stories from around the country, we highlight the worst story each month. 

For September, it is the police brutality case of Christina West.  Not because this case is a particularly unique or rare an occurrence, but because it puts such a visceral image to the problem of police brutality.