Cato Policy Analysis No. 401 May 24, 2001

Policy Analysis

Needless Entanglements:
Washington's Expanding Security Ties in
Southeast Asia

by Doug Bandow

Doug Bandow is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and the author of Tripwire: Korea and U.S. Foreign Policy in a Changed World (Cato Institute).


Executive Summary

The end of the Cold War has reduced the danger to the United States everywhere in the world, including Southeast Asia, but Washington hasn't seemed to notice. Instead of reducing America's commitments and force presence in Southeast Asia, as would be appropriate, the Clinton administration expanded the U.S. role. Washington added new agreements, training exercises, naval visits, weapons transfers, and implicit security guarantees for nations such as Australia, the Philippines, Singapore, and even erstwhile adversary Vietnam. The Bush administration seems determined to continue that course.

There is little that the United States can do to maintain stability in Southeast Asia. Cross-border wars are not threatening to overwhelm the region. If it is not willing to use U.S. forces, there is little Washington can do to prevent such wars from breaking out in the first place. America's security interests in the region are modest, at best, and do not warrant military intervention. Indeed, the region's most serious problems are internal: ruthless repression in Burma, potential disintegration in Indonesia, political unrest in the Philippines. In such cases, a U.S. pressure is apt to prove ineffective at best and counter-productive at worst.

The other concern is aggression from an outside power, namely China, but Beijing's ambitions seem limited to the South China Sea. Even there, China has been only cautiously assertive; its greatest success has come as a result of disarray among its competitors. In particular, the Philippines' lack of a serious military provides an open invitation for Beijing to push its claims to the Spratly Islands.

Instead of entangling itself in squabbles of limited international significance, Washington should encourage friendly states to better arm themselves and to create cooperative relationships with each other, for example, through the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and with reliable outside players, particularly India and Japan. The United States should adopt a lower military profile in the region and abandon expensive and risky commitments that no longer serve the interests of the American people.

Full Text of Policy Analysis No. 401 (PDF, 30 pgs, 172 Kb)

2001 The Cato Institute
Please send comments to webmaster