Cato Policy Analysis No. 314 September 1, 1998

Policy Analysis

Okinawa:
Liberating Washington's East Asian Military Colony

by Doug Bandow

Doug Bandow, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, was a special assistant to President Reagan and is the author of Tripwire: Korea and U.S. Foreign Policy in a Changed World.


Executive Summary

U.S. military bases on Okinawa, home to some 27,000 service personnel and nearly as many family members, occupy one-fifth of the island. Although being stationed in an attractive western Pacific locale may be pleasant for U.S. soldiers, the pervasive American military presence harms most Okinawans. Barbed-wire-topped fences line major roads and cut across towns; prime commercial sites and beaches are unavailable for civilian use; accidents, crowding, and crime are constant annoyances; live-fire military exercises and aircraft flights disrupt what would otherwise be a peaceful environment. Okinawan demands for a reduction in the number and size of U.S. bases have been growing, especially since the election of Masahide Ota as governor in 1990.

The pervasive U.S. presence, made possible by America's conquest of the island during World War II, is a relic of the Cold War. The end of the Cold War and the transformation of the strategic environment of East Asia have eliminated the need to deploy the Third Marine Expeditionary Force and other military units stationed on the island--as well as elsewhere in Japan. Proposals for new missions--such as providing support for humanitarian interventions--are merely pretexts to preserve bases that have outlived their usefulness.

After more than half a century of U.S. occupation, the majority of Okinawans want the American troops to start going home. It is time for Washington to oblige by phasing out its troop presence, not only in Okinawa but in the rest of Japan as well, as recently recommended by former Japanese prime minister Morihiro Hosokawa.

Full Text of Policy Analysis No. 314 (PDF, 27 pgs, 71 Kb)

1998 The Cato Institute
Please send comments to webmaster