Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
The Pakistani
conflict. The contrasting considerations of
power in South Asia in which India remained
U.S. and Pakistani national interests were
the leading military player. In fact, during the
nuclear program
clearly demonstrated in the growing ties
first three years of the Carter administration,
was a form of
between Islamabad and communist China in
the process of détente with the Soviet Union,
diplomatic black-
the 1960s and by the disastrous decision by
as well as the focus on human rights and
Pakistan to launch a war against India over
nuclear proliferation by the White House and
mail in
Kashmir in 1965, which led to Pakistan's mil-
Congress, meant that differences in national
Islamabad's rela-
itary defeat when the administration of
interests and values significantly weakened
Lyndon Johnson refused to bail out
U.S.-Pakistani ties. Evidence that Pakistan
tionship with
Islamabad from the mess it had created.
was accelerating the development of its
Washington.
The tensions between Pakistan and the
nuclear program, and Zia's military coup that
United States were reflected in another devel-
ousted the elected government of Zulfikar Ali
opment. Beginning in the 1970s Pakistan
Bhutto, brought relations to a nadir.
moved to develop a nuclear weapons capabil-
Pakistan's Reemergence as a Useful
ity to offset India's advantage in conventional
Client State in the 1980s
military power and as a response to India's
detonation of a nuclear device in 1974. The
Even before Zia arrived in Washington in
Pakistani nuclear program was also a form of
1982, however, there were indications that
diplomatic blackmail in Islamabad's relation-
not only was Pakistan reasserting its position
ship with Washington. Pakistani officials
as a useful client state for Washington but
insisted that only a sufficient supply of
that the normal pattern of relations between
American conventional arms would prevent
the global power, the United States, and the
Pakistan from going nuclear. But Pakistan's
client state, Pakistan, which had been evident
effort to become a nuclear power ran contrary
during most of the Cold War, was beginning
to another core U.S. national security interest:
to change in favor of the latter. The principal
working to block the proliferation of nuclear
reason for that change was the Soviet inva-
weapons and creating a stable international
sion of Afghanistan and the decision, first by
nuclear arms control regime (both during
the Carter administration and then by
and after the Cold War). The divergent goals
President Ronald Reagan and his advisers, to
of the two countries on the nuclear issue led
use Pakistan as a base to support the
to numerous diplomatic showdowns (espe-
mujahideen in Afghanistan as part of a strat-
cially under pressure from Congress).
egy to oust the Soviets from that country.
When one analyzes the relationship
That Pakistan was able to strengthen its
between Washington and Pakistan before the
leverage over Washington was a result of
Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979, what
global and regional developments. One
emerges is the normal pattern of relationship
development was increasing anti-Soviet
between a great power and a client state. Each
cooperation between the United States and
side refrained from abandoning its commit-
China. Pakistan could be integrated into that
ments to its respective core national interests,
cooperation since it was a friend of both
but Pakistan was eventually forced to back
countries. Another development was the
down from its aggressive pursuit of those
expansion of ties between Pakistan and the
interests. Indeed, the limits of U.S. support
Arab countries, led by oil-rich Saudi Arabia
led to the partition of Pakistan and the estab-
and bolstered by the rising global economic
lishment of Bangladesh following India's
power of the oil cartel, OPEC, that was exert-
military victory in its 1971 war with Pakistan.
ing enormous pressure on U.S. foreign poli-
In those and other cases, Washington was
cy. Many of the Arab states regarded Pakistan
not willing to provide Pakistan with the mili-
not only as a strategic ally (containing Soviet
tary and diplomatic support needed to
expansionism toward the Middle East) but
change in any dramatic way the balance of
also as a religious and cultural associate com-
8