Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Station a notable holding) to nil (a shelter
ple is the New York Metropolitan Transpor-
and platform in some small towns). Asset dis-
tation Authority, which on behalf of the
position is not an issue with many stations
Long Island Rail Road has attempted to gain
used by Amtrak because the structures are
control of two of the tunnels that lead into
Manhattan's Penn Station.72
owned by others such as regional commuter
rail agencies (for example, Los Angeles Union
On some commuter rail systems else-
Passenger Terminal) and local communities
where, Amtrak provides various degrees of
(for example, Irvine, California). In many
train dispatching, ticket collection, and
places the freight railroads continue to own
maintenance services. It is virtually certain
passenger stations in which Amtrak's inter-
that the private sector will be interested in
est is that of a tenant.
bidding on those contracts, and private com-
Freight Terminals. Highly uncertain is the
panies now operate parts of commuter train
fate of Amtrak freight terminals, which in
operations in Chicago, Los Angeles, San
many cases are located in or adjacent to exist-
Diego, San Jose, and Dallas.
ing railroad freight yards. A listing of the ter-
Amtrak commuter contracts (operations
and/or maintenance) are73
minals includes but is not limited to
Chicago, Oakland, Louisville, Detroit,
Amtrak is periph-
· Maryland
Jeffersonville, Indiana, Kansas City, Dallas,
Rail Commuter Service
eral to the opera-
and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.67
(Maryland and District of Columbia)
· Massachusetts Bay Transportation
Maintenance Bases. Amtrak owns mainte-
tions of the three
nance facilities in Boston, New York City,
Authority  (Massachusetts,  Rhode
largest commuter
Washington, D.C., and Wilmington and
Island)
· Metrolink (Los Angeles)
rail systems in
Bear, Delaware, whose futures will be
· The Coaster (San Diego)
brighter if they are run by an innovative fran-
the United States.
· CalTrain (San Francisco­San Jose)
chise operator. Amtrak's heavy overhaul base
· Virginia Railway Express (Virginia and
at Beech Grove, Indiana, has potential as a
privatized operation, particularly as Amtrak
District of Columbia)
· Shoreline East (Connecticut)
has assigned to the facility contact work on
· Sound Transit (Seattle)74
transit cars used in city subway systems.
Other maintenance facilities serve routes
with a high likelihood of continued opera-
Potential Purchasers and
tion under a franchise system and include
Franchise Operators
Chicago, Hialeah, Florida, Los Angeles, New
Orleans, Niagara Falls, Oakland, Rensselaer,
New York, Seattle, and Washington, D.C.68
There has been significant private-sector
interest in the potential for rail franchising in
Commuter Operating Contracts
the United States. Domestic companies exam-
It should be noted that Amtrak is periph-
ining such options include Peter Pan Bus
eral to the operations of the three largest
Lines and Railway Service Corporation, and
commuter rail systems in the United States--
overseas interest is being expressed by British
the Long Island Rail Road in New York,
train operators Great Western Trains,
which carried 85.3 million people in 2000;69
Stagecoach, Virgin Management Group, and
Metro-North Railroad, also serving New
GB Rail. The possible candidates for assuming
York, which carried 71.8 million passengers
the contracts for commuter rail operations
last year;70 and Chicago's Metra Commuter
include Herzog Transit Services of Missouri,
System, which served 82 million passen-
which already holds commuter train contracts
gers.71 Some commuter lines that are depen-
in Florida, Texas, and California, and Connex,
dent on Amtrak already have sought greater
which is examining state-contracted regional
trains as well as commuter trains.75
control over their own operations. An exam-
13