Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Almost everyone
paladares), salsa bars, or sexual companions are
goods can be found besides in a flourishing
often harassed and sometimes arrested. (It is
black market that illegally offers everything
needs to moon-
true, as some Cubans argue, that hustlers and
from foods to cigars to services. It is common
light to get dol-
omnipresent beggars can become a nuisance
to meet highly trained doctors or educators
lars so he can buy
to visitors, so cops on every corner may also be
driving taxis, renting out rooms in their
there in part to "protect" the tourists.) Private
houses, acting as travel guides, or involved in
food and other
restaurants in people's houses, which operate
prostitution. One Cuban who rents a couple
items in "dollar"
under strict (but not always enforced) guide-
of rooms in his house, and pays about half
lines, open and close frequently depending on
the earnings to the state in taxes, still makes
stores.
the whim of the government. Many paladares
20 times what he did before as a geological
engineer.1 8 And an attractive lady can earn
have closed in recent months in Havana, and
over the past year the number of paladares in
more in two nights than a state-paid neuro-
Cienfuegos, according to residents of the area,
surgeon does in a month. Many of the lithe
has declined from 19 to 3, in large part
and lovely mulatas at the world-famous
because the cost of licenses was increased to
Tropicana nightclub in Havana are available
more than $800 per month.1 6 Private art gal-
after hours for gentlemen who will supple-
ment their meager state-paid salaries. The
leries on the popular Obispo Street in Havana
division between the people with and the
were closed between our visits in February and
people without dollars has created major
April. Economy Minister José Luis Rodríguez
problems for the government. The country's
said on television in April: "We believe there's
leaders know U.S. dollars keep the economy
no reason for the self-employed sector not to
moving and, when they are sucked in by
exist, if it follows certain regulations. But we
state-run dollar stores, provide the state des-
don't stimulate it because we don't think it's
the solution to our economic problems."1 7
perately needed hard currency. But only half
to three-quarters of Cubans have access to
The government strategy seems to be to allow
those dollars, in very differing amounts,
a certain amount of free enterprise but never
whether from family abroad or dollar-earn-
let practitioners take their income for granted.
ing activities in Cuba. Government employ-
The Economic Reality
ees, who are paid in pesos, are particularly
hard hit, and so the state has established pro-
While GDP comparisons are complicated,
duction and other bonuses to reduce but by
particularly since Cuba only recently moved
no means eliminate income discrepancies.19
from Soviet-style statistical methods to inter-
national standards, there is no doubt that the
One criticism often leveled at the Cuban
economy, which was heavily dependent on
government is about how it controls salaries
the Soviet bloc until it collapsed, still has not
received by Cubans who work for foreign
regained 1990 levels. Cuba has a dual-curren-
employers, including the U.S. government.
cy economy, and a foreigner can travel all
When a foreign employer attempts to hire
over the island for a month and never touch
Cuban employees, he must select workers
a peso. (Cubans call their currency "paja-
from a prescreened pool of candidates offered
mas," because it is "for indoor use only.") The
by a Cuban state agency. The agency then
average monthly salary of a government
requires the foreign employer to remit a
worker is about $12, up some 7 percent over
"salary" in hard currency--usually around U.S.
last year. A monthly pension may be no more
$300 per month, payable to the state agency,
than $4. Rationed items, sold at very low
not the individual employee. From this salary,
prices for pesos only, generally last the typical
the state pays the employee with an equal
family considerably less than a month.
number of Cuban pesos, not in convertible
Thus almost everyone needs to moonlight
pesos that in Cuba are equal to one U.S. dollar.
to get dollars so he can buy food and other
This exchange translates into an effective tax
items in "dollar" stores, the only places many
rate of about 95.5 percent, which the govern-
5