Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Page 29
concluded that "the applicant's uncorroborated testimony
will be insufficient to meet the evidentiary burden unless
it is credible. . . . Credibility is enhanced when the
applicants describe events with specificity, coherence,
internal consistency, and clarity.  Credibility is undercut
by generalities, avoidance of eye contact, evasiveness and
apparent uncooperation in answering questions (some of
which) may be the consequence of the experiences that caused
the applicant to seek asylum."  In addition, physicians have
found that asylum seekers' "shame and humiliation, anxiety,
memory impairments and lack of trust often lead to confusing
and apparently contradictory statements."  Therefore, asylum
applicants may need to undergo extensive treatment and
prepare thoroughly before they are able to communicate
coherently about their persecution.  Physicians for Human
Rights, Medical Testimony on Victims of Torture, p. 13.
50. See Rose Collantes Peters, "Applying for Asylum," Ameri-
can University Journal of International Law and Politics 9
(1994): 245.
51. Moreover, the lawyer must meet with the client to ascer-
tain the details of the claim (which often takes numerous
meetings), and the applicant must be rehearsed and prepared
for the interview.  All of that may take longer than one
might initially expect, given that many asylum applicants do
not speak English fluently and suffer from the side effects
of PTSD.
52. Mark Krikorian, "Who Deserves Asylum?" Commentary, June
1996, pp. 52-54.
53. Pamela Constable, "Togolese Teen Criticizes Detainment,"
Washington Post, April 30, 1996, p. A3.
54. Interview of Fauziya Kasinga on ABC's Nightline, May 3,
1996.
55. Board of Immigration Appeals, "In re Kasinga," Interim
Decision no. 3278, Falls Church, Virginia, 1996.  See Musa-
lo, "In re Kasinga: A Big Step Forward for Gender-Based
Asylum Claims," Interpreter Releases 73 (July 1, 1996): 853.
56. Pamela Goldberg, "U.S. Law and Women Asylum Seekers:
Where Are They and Where Are They Going?" Interpreter Re-
leases 73 (July 8, 1996): 889, 896-97.  Over the two years
ending December 31, 1995, 40,000 refugee claims were filed,
483 of which were granted on the basis of gender claims.