Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Page 2
Introduction
Throughout its history, the United States has been a
refuge for oppressed peoples from around the world.  The
Pilgrims, the Quakers, the Amish, and countless others came
to these shores in centuries past, while in the more recent
past immigrants have been Cubans, Jews, Southeast Asians,
and others.  What those diverse people shared was a belief
that America could offer them refuge from government oppres-
sion.
Many people worldwide today face similar oppression;
they live under governments that forbid them to freely
exercise rights that Americans hold dear as fundamental
freedoms and persecute them when they try.  We grant politi-
cal asylum to such persons: as a nation, we believe that
government oppression because of one's race, religion,
political opinion, nationality, or social group is wrong.
Oppression undermines our fundamental values.  Thus, we
traditionally have granted sanctuary to victims of human
rights abuses from around the world.
Through its refugee and asylum protection policies, the
United States has always been at the forefront of protection
issues, serving as a leader in garnering international
attention and responses to refugee and humanitarian emergen-
cies around the world.  America's example has great influ-
ence on how other countries respond to refugees.
Notwithstanding this grand tradition of leadership in
refugee protection, portions of a law passed by Congress,
the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility
Act of 1996 (IIRIRA),1 impose procedural hurdles that in
many cases may prevent genuine victims of persecution from
attaining asylum.  The intention of the law was to reduce
abuses, both real and perceived, in the asylum system, even
though key reforms had already been made by the Immigration
and Naturalization Service.  If the new law does curb abuse,
it does so only at the price of cutting down on all claims
for asylum--without distinguishing between the valid and the
fraudulent.  It could damage one of America's noblest ide-
als, being a safe haven for those fleeing repressive govern-
ments.
The Nature of Governments