Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
business manager, who recommended it as a
The Johnsons are excited but still a bit con-
good option for his business and for him per-
cerned because Maple Middle School costs
sonally--it's a great way to help people and
$5,500 and they only have $4,500 in credits so
donate money instead of letting it be wasted by
far. They speak with the school admissions
the government school bureaucracy, he said.
advisor, and he informs them that the school
Mr. and Mrs. Garcia spoke about it that
has a scholarship fund supported by former
night, and the next day Mr. Garcia met with
students and community businesses which can
his accountant. The Garcias can claim credits
be used to help fill the gap. The Johnsons are eli-
on $22,000 of sales taxes, property taxes that
gible for up to $3,000 in scholarship funds,
fund local schools, and income taxes. They
because their tax liability is only $2,000 and
decided they want to divide the credits among
their child credit cap for each child is $5,000.
a few different scholarship organizations:
Since Mrs. Johnson's employer gave them
$15,000 would go to a scholarship organiza-
$2,500, they can use $500 in scholarship funds.
tion that works with schools that have
The Johnsons and the admissions advisor work
tremendous success raising achievement lev-
out a plan whereby the school scholarship fund
els of children from lower-income families in
will give Jack $500 and the Johnsons will pay
the city; $5,000 would go to a scholarship
the last $500 out of their own pocket without a
organization at a school that specializes in sci-
credit.
ence and math (since Mr. Garcia is an archi-
The school advisor gives them a few papers
tect and Mrs. Garcia is a biologist); and
to fill out, and the Johnsons rest easy knowing
$2,000 would go to the scholarship organiza-
that Jack will be in a school that's a better fit
tion to help families at the school where
this year. And they now know they can get
Isabel is enrolled.
more help for Jill if she needs to switch schools
The Garcias are excited to be able to spend
later on. Mrs. Johnson's employer would
their money directly on schools that work
donate another $2,500 in credits if Jill needed
and the kinds of education that they person-
to find another school, and they would be eli-
ally find important. Finally, with the Public
gible to get Jill another $2,500 in scholarship
Education Tax Credit, they are able to see
funds since they used all of their personal tax
their money make a difference rather than
credits on Jack. The school advisor assures
send it to disappear in the bureaucratic maze
them that they can work out a combination of
of the government school system.
scholarships and payments if they find that
Business. The scenario for businesses is
Maple Middle School or Oak High School is
much the same as the example for a high-
where Jill would do best.
income family, because most businesses are
Upper-Income Family. Mr. and Mrs. Garcia
S-Corps or LLCs, where business income is in
have one child, Isabel, and a family income of
many ways equivalent to individual income.
$200,000. They live in a state that spends
All corporations are allowed to claim tax
$10,000 per student in the government system.
credits for donations to scholarship organi-
Because their income is more than six times the
zations and expenses incurred in support of a
Free or Reduced-Price Lunch Program, they
qualifying student's education expenses.
can't use any Public Education Tax Credits for
The Public Education Tax Credit Act is
Isabel. But they can claim credits on 100 per-
model legislation that doesn't address each
cent of their state tax liability for donating
state's specific taxes. Businesses should, how-
money directly to another family or to a schol-
ever, be allowed to claim tax credits against
arship fund.
any state business taxes in addition to prop-
Mr. Garcia heard about the state education
erty and income taxes. In addition, business-
tax credit program on a radio news program
es could donate directly to employees or
and talked about it with a friend and business
other parents needing aid for the education
colleague over lunch. His friend said he'd
of their eligible children.
learned about it through his accountant and
35