Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Page 8
are members of the Council to Protect Owners' Rights and
Property on Military Bases.  Starting in 1982 some of them
began subdividing their land as a means of protest.  There
are now about 3,000 so-called one-tsubo (about 40-square-
feet) landowners, people who have gained title to obstruct
U.S. control by refusing to extend the leases on their
land.  The movement began on Okinawa but has expanded to
the mainland as residents have sought to demonstrate their
solidarity with Okinawans.  One of the activists is
Moriteru Arasaki, a noted author and university professor
at Okinawa University.  The organization he represents,
the One-tsubo Landlords Campaign, wants to eliminate all
of the bases.  They want their land returned because their
desire is to "use the land productively and for our
lives."26
The main challenge has been the central government's
willingness to force owners to extend their leases.  Curi-
ously, the U.S. armed forces enjoy a higher legal position
than does the Japanese Self-Defense Force, which must rely
on voluntary contracts.  But the administration of Prime
Minister Ryutaro Hashimoto went to court to force the
prefectural government to provide the relevant signature in
the de facto expropriation of private land for the U.S.
facilities.  Not only landowners but other Okinawans have
protested the stifling U.S. military occupation.  In 1995,
85,000 Okinawans turned out in one major demonstration.
The following year 89 percent of Okinawans casting ballots
voted in favor of reducing the American military pres-
ence.27   Nevertheless, Tokyo and Washington issued a joint
declaration in April 1997, supplemented by another accord
a year later, affirming the continued presence of U.S.
military forces.
If Tokyo and Washington do not come up with meaning-
ful relief, Okinawan anger is likely only to rise.  Ota
worries that some residents may resort to violence.  Choko
Takayama, deputy mayor of Naha city, argues, "If the U.S.
wants to keep its forces in the region long-term, it needs
to take action, like folding Futenma Air Station into
Kadena Air Base."28
Collusion between Tokyo and Washington
An important cause of Okinawans' frustration is the
fact that their pleas are ignored in Tokyo as well as in
Washington.  Unfortunately, the American base presence in
Okinawa provides no cause for complaint by Tokyo.  Three-
quarters of U.S. facilities are now concentrated on 0.6
percent of Japan's land area, which also happens to be the