Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Page 2
Introduction
Thirteen-year-old Rebecca Sealfon of Brooklyn, New
York, brought new attention to the growing phenomenon of
homeschooling when she became the first homeschooled child
to win the National Spelling Bee.  She was one of 17 home-
schooled students among 245 competitors in the 70th annual
bee, held in May 1997.1
The rise of homeschooling, of course, reflects broaden-
ing dissatisfaction with formal education in the United
States.  From its modest beginnings in one-room schoolhous-
es, American education has grown into a gargantuan govern-
ment enterprise.  Today, about 50 million students attend
more than 85,000 public schools and more than 26,000 private
schools.2  Education is the largest line item in most state
budgets.  The average per pupil expenditure in America's
public schools is $6,993.3
Ironically, given the amount of money expended on
teaching young people, public dissatisfaction with America's
schools is high.  In a Gallup Poll, "The Public's Attitudes
toward the Public Schools," 45 percent of the respondents
gave America's schools low grades--C, D, or F.4
Dissatisfaction is high for two reasons.  First, Ameri-
can public schools are turning out a poor product--illiter-
ate and unprepared graduates.  For example, American 13-
year-olds have been documented as having math skills that
rank below those of 13-year-olds in 14 other developed
countries.5  One survey noted that only one in three high
school juniors could place the Civil War in the right half
century.6  Not coincidentally, American companies are spend-
ing billions of dollars a year on remedial education for
their employees.7
Equally troubling, public schools have become crime
scenes where drugs are sold, teachers are robbed, and home-
made bombs are found in lockers.  A Metropolitan Life study
released in 1993 reported that over 10 percent of teachers
and 25 percent of students had been victims of violence at
or near their public schools.8
To compound the problem, teachers' unions, school offi-
cials, and many politicians adamantly oppose the use of
public monies for innovative solutions, such as vouchers and
charter schools.  Those alternatives, although not a panacea