Page 9
105th Congress. And Congress has responded to the promise
of pork with gusto: Individual members have proposed hun-
dreds of expensive projects in their districts. The demand
for seats at the table when the decisions are made has been
so great that the House Transportation and Infrastructure
Committee, with 73 members, has become by far the largest
committee in Congress. At 50 members, the House Subcommit-
tee on Surface Transportation may be one of the largest
subcommittees in congressional history.
Proposals for Change
Three basic proposals for reauthorization have been on
the table:
· "NEXTEA," proposed by the administration, basically
would continue ISTEA for another six years.
· "Step 21" is an alternative favored by those states
that end up "donating" more in gas taxes than they
receive in federal funding. This proposal requires
that each state get at least 95 percent of the funds it
pays into the highway fund. It also reduces ISTEA's
many categories of funds to two: a highway fund and a
flexible "surface transportation" fund.
· "TEA-2," sponsored by Mack and Kasich, would devolve
most policy decisions and funds back to the states. It
would eliminate all but about 6 cents of the federal
gas tax. Four cents would still go to deficit reduc-
tion, and 2 cents would be dedicated to maintenance of
the interstate system. The states could then increase
gas or other taxes and make their own decisions about
transportation funding.
Bud Shuster (R-Pa.), chairman of the House Committee on
Transportation and Infrastructure, has made no secret of his
opposition to devolution. "There is a clear federal role in
transportation which must be maintained and strengthened,"
he says. His main goal is to get the trust fund "off bud-
get" so that, except for the 4 cent deficit-reduction tax,
it is protected from raids by other congressional commit-
tees.
ISTEA Interest Groups
Five different interest groups are making common cause
to renew ISTEA: