Cato Institute
Policy Analysis
<<  <  >  >>
Page 5
service allowed people to live on large lots, away from the
congestion in the city centers.  By the 1960s a majority of
Americans lived not in rural areas or cities but in suburbs.
By the 1980s most jobs were also located in the suburbs as
employers followed their workers away from urban congestion.
Increased mobility improved American life in many other
ways.  Drawing on a huge consumer base, stores could provide
increased variety and reduced prices.  A typical American
grocery store in 1900 offered about 3,000 different prod-
ucts.  By the 1950s supermarkets were offering 15,000 dif-
ferent products.  Today some superstores sell well over
100,000 different products.
Automotive technology also gave urbanites a greater
appreciation for nature, and urban residents demanded more
parks and open space within the cities as well as wilderness
and other recreation areas outside the cities.  Fortunately,
the spread of the suburbs allowed the creation of many types
of open space, from large back yards to greenbelts and
forest parks such as those in New York, Chicago, and St.
Louis.
Problems for Cities
The automobile is not without its problems, of course.
Air pollution is an obvious problem, but more subtle is the
tension between the central cities and the suburbs.  Central
city officials consider the suburbs parasites, benefiting
from city services but failing to pay their share of taxes.
Suburbanites have often successfully opposed annexation,
city-county consolidation, and other attempts by the central
cities to absorb the suburbs into their tax bases.
For many city officials, the most upsetting thing about
the suburbs is not that they seem to be parasites on the
cities but that the suburbs do not even need the cities.
With jobs, shopping areas, and various cultural facilities
moving to the suburbs, central city downtowns have declined
in importance.  In fact, as Frank Lloyd Wright realized as
early as 1922, the invention of the telephone, automobile,
and electric lighting made downtowns obsolete.  Joel Gar-
reau, author of Edge City, points out that "we have not
built a single old-style downtown from raw dirt in seventy-
five years."4
City officials and planners have viewed the decline of
downtowns as a crisis and responded in various ways.  In the
1950s they combined "urban renewal," which often proved